Ufa Archaeological Herald

The article overviews the interregional and local connections between groups of the Belozerka culture in the Northern Black Sea region. Earlier these connections were traced on the base of contemporary typology (metal items, partly ceramics, products made of different materials) and mapping. A recent research basing relies on the isotopic geochemical signatures (⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr) and is evident of the mobility of people from the coastal marine settlement Bai-Kiyat I (North-Western Crimea). This is the first archaeometric study of ceramics from the sites and burials of the steppe zone (the mouth of the Southern Bug, the Low Dniester region, the North-Western Crimea). There are similar recipes of ceramic pastes for pottery making on the Dikyi Sad fortress (the mouth of the Southern Bug) and in the Shirochansky burial ground (the Low Dnieper region). Several potteries found in these sites are identified as imported. A part of them is from the Carpathian-Danube region as well as other regions yet unknown. It is determined that one of the markers of ceramic production of the Belozerka culture bearers is crushed bones added as a temper to ceramic paste. All obtained data suggest diversification of the economic and production activity of the groups of the later stage of the Belozerka culture. As a result, a net of small local various manufactures was developed that facilitated the local communication and exchange of different types of products. The study of archaeological materials with complex precision analytic methods and matching with data of comparative typology and mapping supports the idea that the area of the Belozerka culture featured different, multi-vector interregional connections of high intensity. This explains the heterogeneity and mosaic nature of the Belozersk culture, but also serves as evidence of deterioration of previously established routes of interaction between different communities in Southeastern Europe and the Northern Black Sea region. The reorientation of external ties and the significant expansion of local contacts, along with many other factors (a crisis in metal production, technology transfer, and innovations in several technological fields related to the mastery of high temperatures by ancient craftsmen (bimetallic/iron-bronze products, raw steel and genuine mine iron, "Belozersk" glass, high-quality polished ceramics), are the most important characteristics of the final Bronze Age in ancient Europe.

Southeastern Europe, Northern Black Sea region, Late Bronze Age, Belozerka culture, natural science analysis, ceramics, interregional and local communications

• Agulnikov, S.М., 2003, “Burial rite of the Kazaklysky cemetery of the Belozersk culture”, Interferenţe cultural-cronologice in spaţiul nord-pontic, red. șef. E. Sava. Instututului de arheologie și etnografie AȘM, Kishinev, pp. 139–163. (In Russ.)
• Agulnikov, S.M., 2005, “Chronology and periodization of the Belozersk sites of the Prut-Dniester interfluve”, Revista Arheologică, s.n., vol. I(1), pp. 77–91. (In Russ.)
• Agulnikov S.М., 2018, “ About topography and planning of Belozerskaya culture cemeteries”, Ancient necropolises – funeral and memorial ritualism, architecture and planning of necropolises, ed. by Nosov, E.N. IHMC RAS, The State Hermitage Museum, St. Petersburg, pp. 79–85 (Proceedings of the IHMC RAS, vol. 47). (In Russ.)
• Bochkarev, V.S., 1981, “Variability and Tradition in Metalworking (Based on Materials from the Late Bronze Age of the Northern Black Sea Region)”, Continuity and Innovation in the Development of Ancient Cultures: Proceedings of the Methodological Seminar of the Leningrad Branch of the Institute of Archaeology of the USSR Academy of Sciences, ed. by Masson, V.M. & Boryaz, V.N. Nauka, Leningrad, pp. 22–27. (In Russ.)
• Bochkarev, V.S., 2017, “Stages of development of metal production in the Late Bronze Age in the south of Eastern Europe”, Stratum plus, No. 2, pp. 159–204. (In Russ.)
• Bochkarev, V.S., Kashuba, М.Т., 2018, “The cultural and historical situation in the south of Eastern Europe on the eve of the Iron Age”, Stratum plus, No. 3, pp. 207–220. (In Russ.)
• Bochkarev, V., Kashuba, М., 2020, “The transition from bronze to iron: the Ferraaeneum period in Eastern Europe”, Iron Age Europe without borders. The first millennium BC: exhibition catalog, the collective of authors, ed. by Alekseev, A.Yu. et al. Chisty List publishing house, St. Petersburg, pp. 41–64. (In Russ. and Germ.)
• Vanchugov, V.P., 1990, Belozersk sites in the northwestern Black Sea region. The development of the Belozersk culture. Naukova dumka, Kiev, 168 p. (In Russ.)
• Vanchugov, V.P., 1996, “On the social structure of the population of the Belozersk culture (based on materials from burial sites)”, Ancient Black Sea Region, III Readings in Memory of Professor Petr Osipovich Karyshkovsky, March 12–14, 1996, ed. by Stanko, V.N. Astroprint, Odessa, pp. 23–24. (In Russ.)
• Vanchugov, V.P., 1997, “Funeral rite of the Belozersk culture of the Northwestern Black Sea region (an experiment in social reconstruction)”, Archaeology and Ethnology of Eastern Europe. Materials and Research (a collection of scientific papers dedicated to the 60th anniversary of V.N. Stanko), ed. by Bulatovich, S.A. Germes, Odessa, pp. 154–167. (In Russ.)
• Vanchugov, V.P., 2013, “Belozersk culture”, Ancient cultures of the Northwestern Black Sea region (on the 95th anniversary of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine), ed. by Bruyako, I.V. & Samoylova, T.L. Odessa Archaeological Museum, Odessa, pp. 316–334. (In Russ.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., 2016, “The main aspects of the material culture of the Dikyi Sad settlement”, Eminak, No. 4(16), pp. 19–32. (In Russ.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., 2018, “Vessels from the “Citadel” section of the Dyky Sad fortified settlement”, Arheologia, No. 4, pp. 28–46. (In Ukr.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., 2019, “Vessels from the ditch of the “Citadel” section of the Dyky Sad fortified settlement “, Arheologia, No. 2, pp. 19–39. (In Ukr.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., 2020, “Remains of the buildings of the “citadel” of the Dyky Sad fortified settlement”, Antiquities of Lukomorie, No. 1(1), pp. 5–44. (In Ukr.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., Goshko, Т.Yu., 2010, “Metal products from the settlement of Dyky Sad”, Arheologia, No. 1, pp. 97–111. (In Ukr.)
• Gorbenko, К.V., Grebennikov, Yu.S., Smirnov, А.I., 2011, Steppe Troy of Nikolaev region, 2nd ed., suppl. Irina Gudym's publishing house, Nikolaev, 48 p. (In Russ.)
• Goroshnikov, A.A., Goroshnikova, Z.V., Smekalova, T.N., Antipenko, A.V., 2023, “The Composition of the Alloy of Metal Objects from the Excavations of the Late Bronze Age Settlement of Bagay 1 in the North-Western Crimea”, Stratum plus, No. 2, pp. 319–336. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.55086/sp232319336
• Goroshnikov, A.A., Goroshnikova, Z.V., Mimokhod, R.А., Usachuk, A.N., 2025, “The complex of material finds of the Late Bronze Age settlement Bagai 1 in the North-Western Crimea”, Caucasus and the Circumpontic in Antiquity: Materials, Studies, Hypotheses, ed. by Kleshchenko, A.A., Kashuba, M.T. IA RAS, Moscow, pp. 94–110. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.25681/IARAS.2025.978-5-94375-478-4.94-110
• Goshko, Т.Yu., 2019. “Metal composition of items in the Dikyi Sad hoard”, Stratum plus, No. 2, pp. 161–166. (In Russ.)
• Evdokimov, G.L., 1987, “A burial ground from the Belozersk period near the village of Pervomayevka”, The oldest pastoralists of the steppes of southern Ukraine, ed. by A.I. Terenozhkin. Naukova dumka, Kiev, pp. 107–126. (In Russ.)
• Zaytsev, Yu.P., Kashuba, M.T., Kulkova, M.A., Kulkov, A.M., Tikhomirov, V.A., Shkriblyak, I.I., 2024, Bronze Age – Early Iron Age metal items from the funds of the Museum-Reserve “Naples Scythian”. Random deposit finds (2015, 2018–2023). Herzen State Pedagogical University, St. Petersburg, 248 p. (In Russ.)
• Kashuba, М.Т., 2013, “"Eluding" iron: the transition to the Early Iron Age in the East Carpathian region”, Russian Archaeological Yearbook, No. 3, pp. 233–257. (In Russ.)
• Kashuba, М.Т., 2017, “Ideas and materials at the end of the Bronze Age in the west of the North Black Sea region”, Ex Ungue Leonem: A collection of articles dedicated to the 90th anniversary of Lev Samuilovich Klejn, ed. by Vishnyatsky, L.B. Nestor-History publishing house, St. Petersburg, pp. 139–150. (In Russ.)
• Kashuba, М.T., 2025, “Unobvious functions of metal fragments in the Late Bronze Age hoards of the Northern Black Sea region”, Archaeological News, No. 48, pp. 126–134. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.31600/1817-6976-2025-48-126-134
• Kozlenko, R., 2018, “The dwelling of a master bone carver on the outskirts of the Dikyi Sad fortified settlement”, Eminak, No. 3 (23), pp. 111–116. (In Russ.)
• Kolotukhin, V.A., 2000, “The Late Bronze Age settlement of Bai-Kiyat in Crimea”, Stratum plus, No. 2, pp. 526–553. (In Russ.)
• Kolotukhin, V.A., 2003, The Late Bronze Age of Crimea. Stilos, Kiev, 139 p. (In Russ.)
• Kulkova, M.A., 2024, Adaptation of ancient humans to the natural climatic conditions of the Holocene and their role in the formation of the integrated geosystem of Eastern Europe. Herzen State Pedagogical University, St. Petersburg, 332 p. (In Russ.)
• Kulkova, M.A., Kashuba, M.T., Kulkov, A.M., Vetrova, M.N., Streltsov, M.A., 2023, “Microprobe analysis (SEM-EDX) of artifacts from Bronze Age – Early Iron Age sites in the Northern Black Sea region”, Russian nanotechnology (=Nanobiotechnology Reports), vol. 18 (6), pp. 832–842. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.56304/S1992722323050102
• Kulkova, M.A., Kashuba, M.T., Kulkov, A.M., Kozhukhovskaya, Yu.V., Tikhomirov, V.A., Streltsov, M.A., Markova, М.А., 2024, “New evidence on the Late Bronze – Early Iron Age human nutrition in the Crimea (Northern Pontic region) based on the stable isotope analysis and radiocarbon dating”, The Volga River Region Archaeology, No. 4, pp. 104–119. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.24852/pa2024.4.50.104.119
• Leskov, A.M., 1970, “Kirovskoye settlement”, Antiquities of Eastern Crimea (Pre-Scythian period and the Scythians), ed. by Leskov, A.M. Naukova dumka, Kiev, pp. 7–59. (In Russ.)
• Leskov, A.M., 1971а. “Pre-Scythian period in the steppes of the Northern Black Sea region”, Problems of Scythian archeology, ed. by Liberov, P.D. & Gulayev, V.I. Nauka, Moscow, pp. 75–91 (MIA, No. 177). (In Russ.)
• Leskov, О.М., 1971b. “Srubnaya culture”, Archaeology of the Ukrainian SSR. Volume One. Prehistoric Archaeology, ed. by Telegin, D.Ya. Naukova dumka, Kiyv, pp. 404–434. (In Ukr.)
• Leskov, O.M., Kravchenko, E.A., Goshko, T.Yu., 2019, Burial site of the Belozersk culture near the village of Shyroke. Historical and Local History Museum, Maydan, Lviv, Vinniki, 206 p. (In Ukr.)
• Lysenko, S.S., 2021, Jewelry of the population of the Northern Black Sea region of the Late Bronze Age. Stratum plus, Kishinev, Kiev, 688 p. (Archaeological sources of Eastern Europe). (In Russ.)
• Lyashko, S.N., 1994, “Bone carving production in the Bronze Age”, Crafts of the Eneolithic-Bronze Age in Ukraine, ed. by Chernyakov, I.T. Naukova dumka, Kiev, pp. 152–166. (In Russ.)
• Malyarova, А.D., Kulkova, М.А., Kashuba, М.Т., Kulkov, A.M., Sukharzhevskaya, E.S., Kozhukhovskaya, Yu.V., 2025, “On the issue of imported ceramics at the Late Bronze Age settlement of Bai-Kiyat I in Northwestern Crimea”, Geoarchaeology and archaeological mineralogy – 2025: Proceedings of XII All-Russian Scientific Conference with International Participation named after Prof. V.V. Zaykov, ed. by Ankushev, M.N. & Ankusheva, N.N. YuUrGGPU publishing house, Miass, Chelyabinsk, pp. 123–128. (In Russ.)
• Interdisciplinary…, 2020, Interdisciplinary study of Bronze Age settlements of North-Western Crimea: collective monograph, Smekalova, T.N., Kashuba, M.T., Muld, S.A., Lisetskiy F.N., Borisov, A.V., Solomonova, M.Yu., Kashurskaya, N.N., Bevan, B.U., Kulkova M.A., Ocherednoy, A.K., ed. by Smekalova, T.N. Aleteya publishing house. St. Petersburg, 204 p. (Materials for the archaeological map of Crimea, vol. XIX). (In Russ.)
• Otroshchenko, V.V., 1975, “A new mounds ground from the Belozersk period”, Scythian world, ed. by A.I. Terenozhkin. Naukova dumka, Kiev, pp. 193–206. (In Russ.)
• Otroshchenko, V.V., 1985, “Belozersk culture”, Archaeology of the Ukrainian SSR. Volume One. Prehistoric Archaeology, ed. by Telegin, D.Ya. Naukova dumka, Kiyv, pp. 519–526. (In Russ.)
• Otroshchenko, V.V., 1986, “Belozersk culture”, Berezanskaya, S.S., Otroshchenko, V.V., Cherednichenko, N.N., Sharafutdinova, I.N., Bronze Age cultures in Ukraine. Naukova dumka, Kiev, pp. 117–152. (In Russ.)
• Paleoenvironment…, 2024. Paleoenvironment and cultural-historical processes in the North-West Black Sea Region in the Bronze Age – Early Iron Age: the first results of research: [collective monograph], ed. by Kulkova, M.A. & Kashuba, M.T. Herzen State Pedagogical University, St. Petersburg, 336 p. (In Russ.)
• Pankows’ki, V.B., 2007, “Bone and horn industry from the Sabatynovka culture settlement of Novohrygorivka”, Materials and research on the archaeology of Eastern Ukraine. From the Neolithic to the Cimmerians, vol. 7. SNU named V. Dal’, Lugans’k, pp. 234–243. (In Ukr.)
• Pankows’ki, V.B., 2012, “Bone and horn industries of the Late Bronze Age in the Northern Black Sea Region”. Автореф. дис. ... канд. іст. наук. Київ: Інститут археології НАН України, 17 p. (In Ukr.)
• Pankowski, V.B., Gorbenko, K.V., 2019, “The Bronze Hoard from the Fortified Settlement of Dikiy Sad” Stratum plus, No. 2, pp. 121–160. (In Russ.)
• Toshchev, G.N., 1992. “ The Belozersky burial ground Budurzhel in the Danube region”, Russian archeology, No. 3, pp. 19–30. (In Russ.)
• Toshchev, G.N., 2007. Crimea in the Bronze Age. Zaporozhye National University, Zaporozhye, 304 p. (In Russ.)
• Streltsov, M.A., Kulkova, M.A., Kashuba, M.T., Kulkov, A.M., Markova, M.A., 2025, “Database “Geoarchaeology of the Northern Black Sea Region: Interdisciplinary approach”: integration of archaeological, mineralogical, geochemical and paleoecological data for the study of the culture of ancient Crimea”, Geoarchaeology and archaeological mineralogy – 2025: Proceedings of XII All-Russian Scientific Conference with International Participation named after Prof. V.V. Zaykov, ed. by Ankushev, M.N. & Ankusheva, N.N. YuUrGGPU publishing house, Miass, Chelyabinsk, pp. 205–209. (In Russ.)
• Agulnikov, S., 1996, Necropola culturii Belozerka de la Cazaclia. Bibliotheca Thracologica, vol. XIV, Institutul Român de Tracologie, Bucureşti, 116 p..
• Bočkarev, V.S., Leskov, A.M., 1980, Jung- und spätbronzezeitliche Gussformen im nördlichen Schwarzmeergebiet. Prähistorische Bronzefunde, Abt. XIX/1, C.H. Beck, München, 97 S., 22 Taf.
• Gorbenko, K.V., Grebennikov, Y.S., 2009, “The “Dikyi Sad” fortified settlement as a uniting link in the context of economic, political and cultural relation of 1200–1000 BC (the Baltic shore, the Pontic region and the Mediterranean)”, Routes between the Seas: Baltik-Boh-Bug-Pont from the 3^rd to the Middle of the 1^st Millennium BC. Baltic-Pontic Studies, vol. 4, pp. 375–390.
• Hoshko, T., 2023. “Metal ornaments from the burial mound necropolis Chornyanka of the Bilozerka culture (11^th–10^th centuries BC)”, History of science and technology, vol. 13(1), pp. 52–64. https://doi.org/10.32703/2415-7422-2023-13-1-52-64
• Hoshko, T., 2024, “Mysterious beads from Brylivka. Bilozerka culture. Ukraine”, Revista Arheologică, serie nouă, vol. XX, nr. 1, 2024, pp. 184–192. http://doi.org/10.52603/RA.XX.1.2024_10
• Kaiser, E., Kashuba, M., Gavrylyuk, N., Hellström, K., Winger, K., Bruyako, I., Daszkiewicz, M., Gershkovich, Y., Gorbenko, K., Kulkova, M., Nykonenko, D., Schneider, G., Senatorov, S., Vetrova, M., Zanoci, A., 2019, Dataset of the Volkswagen Fond Project no. 90 216 “Early mounted nomads and their vessels. Ceramic analysis project aimed at supporting the reconstruction of socio-economic conditions in mobile populations north of the Black Sea between 1100 and 600 BC”, Zenodo 2019. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3521608
• Kašuba, М., 2008, “Die ältesten Fibeln im Nordpontus. Versuch einer Typologie der einfachen Violinbogenfibeln im südlichen Mittel-, Süd- und Südosteuropa“, Eurasia Antiqua, Bd. 14, S. 193–231.
• Kašuba, M., Lehnhardt, E., Šramko, I., Zadnikov, S., 2019, “Eisenmetallurgie in der Bronzezeit Osteuropas. Die archäologischen Quellen und ihre Interpretation”, Praehistorische Zeitschrift, Bd. 94 (1), S. 158–209. https://doi.org/10.1515/pz-2019-0001
• Kulkova, M.A., Kashuba, M.T., Agulnikov, S.M., Kulkov, A.M., Streltsov, M.A., Vetrova, M.N., Zanoci, A., 2022, “Impact of Paleoclimatic Changes on the Cultural and Historical Processes at the Turn of the Late Bronze—Early Iron Ages in the Northern Black Sea Region”, Heritage, vol. 5 (3), pp. 2258–2281. https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage5030118
• Kulkova, M.A., Kashuba, M.T., Kozhukhovskaya, Yu.V., Tikhomirov, V.V., Kulkov, A.M., 2024, “The first data of strontium isotopic composition of osteological material from the Late Bronze — Early Iron Age settlements of Crimea region”, Minerals, vol. 14 (4), No. 410. https://www.mdpi.com/journal/minerals/special_issues/4P83ZF754K
• Leviţki, O., Agulnicov, S., 2010, “Cultura Belozerka”. Istoria Moldovei. Epoca preistorică şi antică (până în sec. V), ed. by Dergaciov, V. Acad. de Științe a Moldovei, Inst. Patrimoniului Cultural, Centru Arheologie, Chişinău, pp. 381–399.
• Otroshchenko, V.V., 2003, “Radiocarbon chronology of the bilozerka culture – based on barrows near the village of Zapovitne (the "Stepnoy" cementery), The Foundations of Radiocarbon Chronology of Cultures between the Vistula and Dnieper: 4000–1000 BC, ed. by Kośko, A. & Klochko, V. Baltic-Pontic Studies, vol. 12, pp. 336–364.
• Popovici, S., 2023, “Interdisciplinary Research on a Grave of the Belozerka Culture in Cimișlia (Republic of Moldova)”, The Bronze Age in Eastern Europe: multidisciplinary approaches, ed. by Diaconu, V. & Gafincu, A. Editura Istros a Muzeului Brăilei „Carol I”, Brăila; Editura Constantin Matasă, Piatra-Neamţ, pp. 135–145.