Ufa Archaeological Herald

In the late 20 century, archaeologists discovered some burial sites of the barbarian elite in the Ordos Plateau dated to 3rd century BC (late Warring States period). Among them Aluchaideng, Sigoupan M2 and Nalingaotu tombs contained burial goods made of precious metals in the style of Pazyryk and Sagly cultures in Altai-Sayan mountain region. There were finials with figures of an upstanding eagle and a hoofed eagle-headed deer-horned phantastic animal with bird heads at the tips of its horns (“hoofed griffin”), a torc with lying animals facing each other. Other items with ‘hoofed griffin’ images and images of a griffin with deer horns and feline body were collected here. There were also ornaments with images of a ram with the twisted body wrapped around its head, ‘swirling’ griffinheads, rooster heads, waterfowls, full-face ‘smiling’ cat heads, flame-shaped figures with ‘commas’ inside. All of the above mentioned artifacts and images have exclusive analogies in Pazyryk culture. As far back as in 1999, the author suggested that the elite of Ordos nomads of 3rd century BC constituted common religious and, possibly, ethnic unity with the Pazyryk people. New discoveries of  Pazyryk culture kurgans in the south of Mongolian Altai support a idea that the Ordos part of the Pazyryk people might have connected with Mountain Altai directly via Alashan and Transaltai Gobi stony deserts bypassing foreign peoples of Mongolian Plateau and the Hexi Corridor. According to Shiji, people (or its elite) occupying the Ordos Plateau since 4th–3rd up to late 2nd centuries BC were known by the name “Loufan”, and in early 3rd century BC the Loufan people were controlled by the state of Zhao. As the written sources and archaeological evidence suggest, in the 3rd century BC, the north-east part of the Ordos Plateau (where the burials in question are located) was the area claimed by Zhao and Qin states; therefore, the barbarian tribes of the north-east of the Ordos Plateau should have been closely intertwined with these states. These relations are proven by Pazyryk-Ordos style artifacts manufactured in Qin and Zhao and found in barbarian tombs, as well as similar objects discovered in the Qin, Zhao and Yan territories. In Sigoupan M2 tomb were found such items bearing Chinese inscriptions of Zhao and Qin states. A large number of similar inscribed artifacts manufactured in Zhao found in Xinzhuantou M30 noble tomb in the Lower Capital of Yan state. It supports the theory that the Ordos barbarians were called Loufan, since as per written sources, Loufan people were included in both Zhao’s and Yan’s administrative systems. Some items identical to the M30 artifacts were found in tombs of Zhao dynasty members in Handan. In tomb of bronze caster of late Warring States period in Xi’an were found ceramic models made for casting bronze or gold decorative plaques in Pazyryk-Ordos style. However, some pictures in this style were represented on artifacts found in the tomb of Qin State Queen Dowager Xia (died in 240 BC). Artifacts with images of “hoofed griffin” are found among Qin state artifacts in Shuihude M47 and Shangwangqun M1 tombs dated to late Warring States period. Moreover, in Xi’an were also found two roof tile-ends with images of a sacred Pazyryk ‘hoofed griffin’ with twisted body. These tiles obviously belonged to luxurious mansion of Warring States period. These artifacts suggest that the Ordos Loufans did not only maintained cultural communication with the Qin state, but also became part of its people.

Ordos Plateau, Warring States, Qin dynasty, state of Zhao, state of Yan, Pazyryk culture, Loufans, elite burials, Shiji

• Borodovsky, A.P., Borodovskaya, E.L. 2013, Archaeological monuments of the mountain valley of the lower Katun in the paleometal era. Novosibirsk: IAEТ SO RAN, 220 p. (In Russ.)
• Dashkovsky, P.K., Meikshan, I.A. 2015, “Elite in the social space of the nomadic society (theoretical and methodical aspect)”, Elita v istorii drevnih i srednevekovyh narodov Evrazii (“Elite in History of Ancient and Medieval peoples of Eurasia”), AltGU, Barnaul, pp. 11–20. (In Russ.)
• Golden deer of Eurasia. A museum catalogue of the exhibition at the State Hermitage Museum 2001. Slavia, Saint Petersburg, 247 p. (In Russ.)
• Kiselev, S.V. 1951, Ancient history of Southern Siberia. AN USSR, Moscow, 642 p. (In Russ.)
• Kovalev, A.A. 1999, “Concerning the connections between Sayan-Altai and Ordos tribes in V–III centuries B.C.”, Itogi izucheniya skifskoj epohi Altaya i sopredel'nyh territorij (“The results of Altai and neighbouring territories scythian epoch study”), AltGU, Barnaul, pp. 75–82. (In Russ.)
• Kovalev, A.A. 2015a, “The tomb Xinzhuangtou M30 – burial of the member of elite of Loufan tribe (Pazyryk culture people) in Yan kingdom’s service (middle 3 c. BC)”, KSIA, iss. 238, pp. 229–241. (In Russ.)
• Kovalev, A.A. 2015b, "On the possibilities to use Chinese written sources for reconstructing the early history of Xiongnu", Transactions of the Institute for the History of Material Culture, no. 12, pp. 176–187. (In Russ.)
• Kovalev, A.A. 2023, “The Dating of Tiles and Tile-Ends Collected during the Archaeologi-cal Survey of Pre-Han “Long Wall” in the North of the Shaanxi Provinc”, Theory and practice of archaeological research, no. 1, pp. 182–196. (In Russ.) DOI: https://doi.org/:10.14258/tpai(2023)35(1).-11
• Kubarev, V.D. 1987, Burial mounds of Ulandryk. Nauka, Novosibirsk, 302 p. (In Russ.)
• Ovsyannikov, V.V. 2011, “The Transformation of the Scythian Deer Image in the Forest-Steppe Ante-Urals”, Izvestiya of Altai State University, no. 4-1 (72), pp. 162–165. (In Russ.)
• Perevodchikova, E.V. 2016, “Golden plaques of wooden vessels from Filippovka 1^st barrow”, Russian Archeology, no. 2, pp. 19–35. (In Russ.)
• Pshenichniuk, A.H. 2012, Filippovka: the necropolis of the nomadic elite of the 4^th century BC on the South Ural. IIYaL UNC RAN, Ufa, 280 p. (In Russ.)
• Rudenko, S.I. 1953, The culture of the Altai Mountain population in the Scythian time. AN SSSR, Moscow, Leningrad, 402 p. (In Russ.)
• Savelev, N.S. 2008, “The Kara-Abuz deer: origins of the image and its transformation”, Trudy II (XVIII) Vserossijskogo arheologicheskogo s"ezda v Suzdale. T. III (“Proceedings of the II (XVIII) All-Russian Archaeological Congress in Suzdal”), vol. III, IA RAN, Moscow, pp. 69–72. (In Russ.)
• Saveliev, N.S. 2014, “Sarmatization of the Southern Urals forest-steppe: background, milestones, characteristics, consequences”, Ufa Archaeological Herald, iss, 14, pp. 191–206. (In Russ.)
• Samashev, Z.S. 2011, Berel. Tajmas, Almaty, 236 p. (In Russ.)
• Stepanova, N.F. 2001, “Hryvnia from the burials of the Scythian time of the Altai Mountains”, Drevnosti Altaya (“The antiquities of Altai”), GAGU, Gorno-Altaysk, pp. 89–94. (Proceedings of the Laboratory of Archeology. No. 7) (In Russ.)
• Fedorov, V.K. 2019, “Filippovka and Aluchayden”, Krym v sarmatskuyu epohu (II v. do n.e. – V v. n.e.). V. Materialy X mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferencii «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii» (“Crimea in the Sarmatian times (the II century BC – the V century AD”), Salta, Simferopol, pp. 300–309. (In Russ.)
• Cheremisin, D.V. 2008, The art of animal style in the burial complexes of the ordinary population of the Pazyryk culture. The semantics of animal images in the context of the funeral rite. IAET SO RAN, Novosibirsk, 136 p. (In Russ.)
• Shulga, D.P., Shulga, P.I. 2017, “Pazyryk entry into Xinjiang”, Vestnik Novosibirskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, Seriya: Istoriya, Filologiya, vol. 16, no. 4: Oriental Studies, pp. 24–29. (In Russ.)
• Shulga, P.I. 2010, Xinjiang in the VIII–III centuries BC (Burial grounds. Chronology and periodization). AltGTU, Barnaul, 238 p. (In Russ.)
• Kovalev, A.A. 2009, “The Location of Loufan tribe in 4–3 century B.C. and Influence of Its Culture to the Culture of Central Plain and South”, The collection of International Symposium on Ordos Bronze Wares, Kesyue chuban'she, Pekin, pp. 383–414.
• Mischke, S., Lee, M.K., Lee, Y.I. 2020, “Climate History of Southern Mongolia Since 17 ka: The Ostracod, Gastropod and Charophyte Record From Lake Ulaan”, Frontiers in Earth Science, vol. 8, article 221. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2020.00221
• Zhang Shuai, Zhao Hui, Sheng Yongwei, Chen Shengqian, Li Guoqiang, Chen Fahu. 2022, “Late Quaternary lake level record of Orog Nuur, southern Mongolia, revealed by optical dating of paleo-shorelines”, Quaternary Geochronology, vol. 72. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quageo.2022.101370
• Batsukh, D., Erdene-Ochir, N. 2017, “Weapons of Mongolian Altai Pazyryk Warriors”, Archaeological studies, vol. XXXVI, fasc. 10, pp. 139–168 (In Mongolian)
• Cheng Linquan, Han Guohe 程林泉, 韩国河. Chang’an Han jing 长安汉镜 (Han mirrors of Chang’an). Xian: Shaanxi renmin chubanshe, 2002, 310 p., 62 pl. (In Chinese)
• Cui Ling 崔睿. Qin Han Guangyan gu cheng ji qi fujin de muzang 秦汉广衍故城及其附近的墓葬 (Qin and Han Guangyan Ancient City and Tombs Nearby), Wenwu, 1977, no 5, pp. 25–37. (In Chinese)
• Dai Yingxin, Sun Jiaxiang 戴应新，孙嘉祥. Shaanxi Shenmu xian chutu Xiongnu wenwu 陕西神木县出土匈奴文物 (Xiongnu cultural relics unearthed in Shenmu County, Shaanxi), Wenwu, 1983, no 12, pp. 23–30. (In Chinese)
• Dai Yingxin 戴应新. Nalingaotu Xiongnu wenwu chutu lüe ji 纳林高兔匈奴文物出土略记 (A brief account of the unearthed cultural relics of the Xiongnu in Nalingaotu), Gugong wenwu yuekan =National Palace Museum Monthly of Chinese Art, 1995, vol. 144, pp. 118–129. (In Chinese)
• Deng Qiuling邓秋玲. Lun Chu guo lingxing wen tong jiang 论楚国菱形纹铜镜 (On the bronze mirrors with diamond-shape patterns of the Chu state), Nanfang wenwu南方文物, 1996, iss. 2, pp. 78–84. (In Chinese)
• Eerduosi shi qingtong qi鄂尔多斯式青铜器 (Ordos style bronzes) / Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin bianzhu 田广金，郭素新编著 (Compiled by Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1986, 402 p., 120 pl. (In Chinese)
• Eerduosi qingtong qi 鄂尔多斯青铜器 (Ordos bronzes) / Eerduosi bowuguan bian 鄂尔多斯博物馆编 (Compiled by Ordos Museum). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2006, 345 p. (In Chinese)
• Eerduosi wenhua yichan 鄂尔多斯文化遗产 (Ordos Cultural Heritage) ／ Chen Yongzhi, Ji Ping, Zhang Wenping zhubian, Neimenggu wenwu kaogu yanjiusuo suobian 陈永志， 吉平， 张文平主编, 内蒙古自治区文物考古研究所编 (Edited by Chen Yongzhi, Ji Ping, and Zhang Wenping, compiled by the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region Cultural Relics and Archaeology Research Institute). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2014. 337 p. (Neimenggu wenhua yichan congshu 内蒙古文化遗产丛书 Inner Mongolia Cultural Heritage Series) (In Chinese)
• Fu Jia’yi傅嘉仪. Zhongguo wadang yishu 中国瓦当艺術 (Art of Chinese tile-ends). Shanghai shudian chubanshe, Shanghai, 2002, 966 p. (In Chinese)
• Guanzhou shi wenwu guanli weiyuan hui, Zhongguo shehui kexueyuan kaogu yanjiusuo, Guanzhou sheng bowuguan 广州市文物管理委員会, 中国社会科学院考古研究所, 广东省博物馆 (Guangzhou Cultural Relics Management Committee, Institute of Archaeology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Guangdong Provincial Museum). Xi Han Nanyue wang mu 西漢南越王墓 (Tomb of the Western Han King of Nanyue). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1991, 555 p., 210 pl. (In Chinese)
• Han shu Di li zhi hui shi 汉书地理志汇释 (Collected explanations to “Dilizhi” chapter of “Hanshu”) / Zhou Zhenhe bianzhu 周振鹤编著 (Compiled by Zhou Zhenhe). Anhui jiaoyou chubanshe, Hefei, 2006, 540 p. (In Chinese)
• Hao Juan, Du Yingwen 郝娟，杜应文. Qin Dongling xin chutu wadang jianshang 秦东陵新出土瓦当鉴赏 (Appreciation of newly unearthed tile-ends from the Qin Dongling Mausoleum), Huaxia wenhua, 2018, no 2, pp. 41–45. (In Chinese)
• Hebei sheng wenwu yanjiusuo 河北省文物研究所 (Hebei Province Cultural Relics Research Institute). Yan xia du 燕下都 (Yan state lower capital). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1996, vol. 1, 947 p., 9 pl.; vol. 2, 56 p., 192 pl. (In Chinese)
• Hou Xiaorong 后晓荣. Zhanguo zhengqu dili Чжаньго чжэнцю дили 战国政区地理 (Political geography of the Warring States period). Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2013, 301 p. (In Chinese)
• Huang Shengzhang 黄盛璋. Xin chu Zhanguo jin yin qi mingwen yanjiu (san ti) 新出战国金银器铭文研究 (三题) (Research on inscriptions on newly discovered Warring States Period gold and silver artifacts (three topics), Gu wenzi yanjiu, 1985, vol. 12, pp. 337–353. (In Chinese)
• Hubei sheng bowuguan 湖北省博物馆 (Museum of Hubei province). 1978 Yunmeng Qin Han mu fajue baogao 1978 年云梦秦汉墓发掘报告 (Report on the Excavation of Qin and Han Tombs in Yunmeng in 1978), Kaogu xuebao, 1986, no. 4, pp. 479–524. (In Chinese)
• Hunan sheng bowuguan 湖南省博物馆 (Museum of Hunan province). Changsha Chu mu 长沙楚墓 (Chu state tombs in Changsha), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2000, 776 p., 173 pl. (In Chinese)
• Jin yin yao shuo mei yi sifang: Jing Ji Jin Yu Shaan wu sheng shi jin yin qi zhang 金银耀烁美熠四方：京冀晋豫陕五省市金银器展 (Gold and silver shine brightly: Gold and silver exhibitions in five provinces and cities including Beijing, Hebei, Shanxi, Henan and Shaanxi), Hebei bowuyuan bian 河北博物院编Музей провинции Хэбэй, Beijing shidai huawen shujiu, Beijing, 2020, 234 p. (In Chinese)
• Linzhou cang zhen麟州藏珍 (Treasures in Linzhou storages) / Zhang Yingxiong zhubian 张应雄主编. Xian renmin meishu chubanshe, Xian, 2009. 185 p. (In Chinese)
• Liuzhu wenming: Shaanxi “shi yi wu” qijian jiben jianshe kaogu zhongyao faxian 2006–2010 留住文明: 陕西"十一五"期间基本建设考古重要发现 2006–2010 (Preserving civilization: important archaeological discoveries in infrastructure construction works during the 11^th Five-Year Plan period in Shaanxi Province, 2006–2010) / 陕西省文物事业管理局, 陕西省考古研究院编Shaanxi sheng wenwu shiye guanli chu, Shaanxi sheng kaogu yanjiusuo bian (Compiled by Shaanxi Provincial Administration of Cultural Heritage, Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology), San Qin chubanshe, Xian, 2011, 261 p. (In Chinese)
• Mengya. Chengzhang. Ronghe. Dong Zhou shiqi beifang qingtong wenhua zhengcui 萌芽·成长·融合——东周时期北方青铜文化臻萃 (Germination·Growth·Integration–The quintessence of northern bronze culture during the Eastern Zhou Dynasty) / Cao Wei zhubian 曹玮主编 (Edited by Cao Wei), San Qin chubanshe, Xian, 2012. 311 p. (In Chinese)
• Nanyang shi wenwu kaogu yanjiusuo 南阳市文物考古研究所 (Nanyang Cultural Relics and Archaeology Institute). Nanyang chutu tong jing 南阳出土铜镜 (Copper mirrors unearthed in Nanyang), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2010, 382 p. 116 pl. (In Chinese)
• Su Hui 蘓辉. Qin San Jin ji nian bingqi yanjiu 秦三晋纪年兵器研究 (Study of weapons with dated inscriptions of the Qin and “Three Jin” states) // Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe, 2013, 297 p. (Chutu wenxian yu gudai wenming congshu / Li Xueqin zhubian 出土文献与古代文明丛书/ 李学勤主编 (Unearthed Documents and Ancient Civilization Series) (In Chinese)
• Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin 田广金，郭素新. Neimenggu Aluchaideng faxian de Xiongnu yiwu 内蒙古阿鲁柴登发现的匈奴遗物 (Xiongnu relics discovered in Aruchaideng, Inner Mongolia), Kaogu, 1980, no. 4, pp. 333–338, 364, 368. (In Chinese)
• Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin田广金，郭素新. Aluchaideng faxian de jin yin qi 阿鲁柴登发现的金银器 (Gold and silver artifacts found in Aluchaiden) // Eerduosi shi qingtong qi 鄂尔多斯式青铜器 (Ordos style bronzes) / Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin bianzhu 田广金，郭素新编著 (Compiled by Tian Guangjin, Guo Suxin), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1986, pp. 342–350. (In Chinese)
• Ren Hucheng, Wang Baoping 任虎成, 王保平. Zhongguo lidai wadang kaoshi. Zhanguo Qin tuxiang juan 2中国历代瓦当考释、战国秦图像 2 (Research and interpretation of tiles of Chinese dynasties, Images of the Warring States and Qin Dynasty. Vol. 2), Shijie tushu chuban, Xian, 2019, 349 p. (In Chinese)
• Shaanxi sheng kaogu yanjiusuo 陕西省考古研究所 (Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology). Qin du Xianyang kaogu baogao 秦都咸阳考古报告 (Archaeological Report on Xianyang, the Capital of Qin). Kexue chubanshe, Beijing, 2004, 800 p., (Shaanxi sheng kaogu yanjiusuo tianye. Di 25 hao. 陕西省考古研究所田野考古报告。第25号 (Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology Field Reports. No. 25) (In Chinese)
• Shaanxi sheng kaogu yanjiusuo 陕西省考古研究所 (Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology). Xian bei jiao Qin mu 西安北郊秦墓 (Qin Tombs in the Northern Suburbs of Xi'an), San Qin chubanshe, Xian, 2006, 416 p. (In Chinese)
• Shaanxi sheng kaogu yanjiuyuan 陕西省考古研究院 (Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology). Shaanxi Chang’an Shenheyuan Zhanguo Qin lingyuan da mu fajue jianbao 陕西长安神禾原战国秦陵园大墓发掘简报 (A brief report on the excavation of the large tomb of the Qin Dynasty in Shenheyuan, Chang'an, Shaanxi), Kaogu yu wenwu, 2021, no. 5, pp. 26–43. (In Chinese)
• Shenmu guibao 神木瑰宝 (Shenmu treasures) / Zhang Youfu, Qu Fengming, Jiang Tao bianzhu 张裕福，屈凤鸣，姜涛编著 (Compiled by Zhang Youfu, Qu Fengming, Jiang Tao), Shaanxi lüyou chubanshe, Xian, 2006, 156 p. (In Chinese)
• Shi Danshe 史党社. Qin yu “rongdi” wenhua de guanxi yanjiu 秦与“戎狄”文化的关系研究 (A Study on the Relationship between Qin and "Rongdi" Culture), Shanghai guju chubanshe, Shanghai, 2022, 220 p. (In Chinese)
• Shi ji 史记 (Records of the Grand Historian) / Sima Qian zhuan 司马迁撰 (Written by Sima Qian). Pei Yin, Sima Zheng, Zhang Shouze - comm. 14^th edition, Zhonghua shuju chubanshe, Beijing, 1996, vol. 1–10, 3322 p., 56 p. (In Chinese)
• Shi Nianhai 史念海. Liang qian san bai nian lai Eerduosi gaoyuan he Hetao pingyuan nong lin mu diqu de fengbu ji bianqian 两千三百年来鄂尔多斯高原和河套平原农林牧地区的分布及变迁 (Distribution and changes of agricultural, forestry and animal husbandry areas in the Ordos Plateau and the Hetao Plain over the past 2,300 years) // Shi Nianhai. He shang ji. San ji. 史念海. 河山集。三集 (Shi Nianhai. Collected works on Mountains and Rivers. Third volume.), Renmin chubanshe, Beijing, 1988, pp. 83–107. (In Chinese)
• Shi Yongshi 石永士, 1997. Hebei sheng jing nei de Yan xia du yizhi 河北省境内的燕下都遗址 (The ruins of Yanxiadu in Hebei Province), Zhonghua wenhua huabao, no 4, pp. 9–19. (In Chinese)
• Wang Shichang 王世昌. Shaanxi gudai zhuan wa tudian 陕西古代砖瓦图典 (Atalas of Shaanxi ancient bricks and tiles). SanQin chubanshe, Xian, 2004, 452 p. (In Chinese)
• Wu Liangbao吴良宝. Zhongguo Dong Zhou shiqi jinshu huobi yanjiu 中国东周时期金属货币研究 (Research on Chinese metal coins of the Eastern Zhou Period), Shehui kexue wenxian chubanshe, Beijing, 2005, 319 p. (Jilin daxue zhexue shehui kexue xueshu wenku 吉林大学哲学社会科学学术文库 (Jilin University Philosophy and Social Sciences Academic Library) (In Chinese)
• Xinjiang Aletai diqu kaogu yu lishi wenji 新疆阿勒泰地区考古与历史文集 (A Collection of Archaeological and Historical Essays in the Altay Region of Xinjiang) / Xinjiang wenwu kaogu yanjiusuo bian 新疆文物考古研究所编 (Compiled by Xinjiang Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2015, 498 p. (In Chinese)
• Yikezhao meng wenwu gongzuo zhan 伊克昭盟文物工作站 (Yikezhao League Cultural Relics Workstation). Neimenggu Dongsheng shi Nianfangqu fajue jinyin qi jiaocang 内蒙古东胜市碾房渠发现金银器窖藏 (A hoard of gold and silver ware discovered in Nianfangqu, Dongsheng City, Inner Mongolia), Kaogu, 1991, no. 5, pp. 405–408, 389. (In Chinese)
• Yikezhao meng wenwu gongzuo zhan 伊克昭盟文物工作站 (Yikezhao League Cultural Relics Workstation). Yijinhuoluo qi Shihuigou fajue de Eerduosi shi wenwu 伊金霍洛旗石灰沟发现的鄂尔多斯式文物 (Ordos-style cultural relics discovered in Shihuigou, Yijinhuoluo Banner), Neimenggu wenwu kaogu, 1992, no. 1–2, pp. 91–96. (In Chinese)
• Yikezhao meng wenwu gongzuo zhan, Neimenggu wenwu gongzuo dui 伊克昭盟文物工作站， 内蒙古文物工作队 (Yikezhao League Cultural Relics Work Station, Inner Mongolia Cultural Relics Work Team). Xigoupan Zhanguo mu 西沟畔战国墓 (Tombs of Zhanguo period in Xigoupan), Eerduosi shi qingtong qi 鄂尔多斯式青铜器 (Ordos style bronzes), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1986, pp. 351–365. (In Chinese)
• Yiyang shi wenwu guanli chu, Yiyang shi bowuguan 益阳市文物管理处, 益阳市博物馆 (Yiyang Cultural Relics Management Office, Yiyang Museum). Yiyang Chu mu 益阳楚墓 (Chu state tombs in Yiyang), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 2008. 413 p. (In Chinese)
• Yulin shi wenwu baohu yanjiusuo 榆林市文物保护研究所 (Yulin Cultural Relics Protection Institute). Yulin shi Yuyang qu Qiaotoumao chengzhi diaocha – jian Xidu, Zhongyan, Pingzhou gu cheng kao 榆林市榆阳区桥头峁城址调查——兼西都、中阳、平周故城考 (Investigation of Qiaotoumao town site in Yuyang District, Yulin City – A study of the ancient towns of Xidu, Zhongyang and Pingzhou), Wenbo, 2019, no. 6, pp. 23–31. (In Chinese)
• Zibo shi bowuguan, Qi gu cheng bowuguan 淄博市博物馆, 齐故城博物馆 (Zibo Museum, Qi Ancient City Museum). Linzi Shangwang mudi 临淄商王墓地 (Shangwang cemetery in Linzi), Qi Lu shushe, Nanyang, 1997, 197 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhanguo ce 战国策 (Strategies of the Warring States) / Liu Xiang jilu刘向集录 (Compiled by Liu Xiang), vol. 1–3, fourth edition, Shanghai gu ji chubanshe, Shanghai, 1995, 1390 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhongguo gudai duiliangheng tuji 中国古代度量衡图集 (Atlas of Ancient Chinese Weights and Measures) / Zhongguo jiliang zongju, Zhongguo lishi bowuguan, Gugong bowuyuan 中国计量总局，中国历史博物馆， 故宫博物院主编 (Edited by China National Metrology Bureau, China History Museum, Palace Museum), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1984, 190 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhongguo lishi dituji 中国历史地图集 (Atlas of Chinese History). Di yi ce. Yanshi shehui, Xia, Shang, Xi Zhou, Chunqiu, Zhanguo shiqi 第一册。原始社会，夏，商，西周，春秋，战国 (Volume 1. Primitive Society, Xia, Shang, Western Zhou, Spring and Autumn, Warring States periods) / Tan Qixiang zhubian谭其骧主编 (Edited by Tan Qixiang), Zhonghua ditu chubanshe, Shanhai, 1996, 46 pl., 63 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhongguo meishu guangji. Jin yin qi boli qi 中国美术全集. 金银器玻璃器 (Complete Collection of Chinese Fine Arts. Gold, Silver and Glassware) / Jin Weinuo zong zhubian, Qi Dongfang juan zhubian 1 金维诺总主编﹔齐东方卷主编1 (Chief Editor: Jin Weinuo; Editor of Vol. 1: Qi Dongfang), Huangshan shushe, Hefei, 2010, 210 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhongguo qingtong qi guangji. Di 16 juan. Tong jing 中国青铜器全集.第16卷.铜镜 (Complete Collection of Chinese Bronzes. Vol.  16. Bronze Mirrors) / Zhongguo qingtong qi guangji bianji weiyuanhui bian 中国青铜器全集编辑委员会编 (Compiled by the Editorial Committee of the Complete Works of Chinese Bronzes), Wenwu chubanshe, Beijing, 1998, 34, 216, 74 p. (In Chinese)
• Zhu Liwei 朱力伟. Dong Zhou yu Qin bingqi mingwen zhongsuo jian de diming东周与秦兵器铭文中所见的地名 (Place names found in the inscriptions on weapons of the Eastern Zhou and Qin periods). Jilin University Master degree Diss. Changchun, 2004, 131 p. (In Chinese)