Ufa Archaeological Herald

In 1963 K.F.Smirnov, V.G.Petrenko, and M.G.Moshkova published two collections of archaeological sources on the Sauromatian culture and the Early Sarmatian (Prokhorovka) culture. At the same time these researchers made a methodological error: using a single archaeological database (card index of monuments), they selected for their publications seventy archaeological complexes and finds, which were both as the latest Sauromatian monuments and as the earliest Sarmatian (Prokhorovka) monuments at the same time. Since the collections of sources were published by category of finds, and not by complexes, the allowed mistake was missed by the authors of the collections when they were preparing the books for publication. And this duplication of materials became a foundation for a system of evidence for the smooth transition of the Sauromatian culture to the Early Sarmatian. When the authors realized this after the books had been published, they decided not to focus on the error believing that the intensive growth of new archaeological material would quickly alleviate the error. However, all the decades after the 1963 incident never gathered sufficient the materi- als of the 3rd century BC. The thesis about the 2nd–1st centuries BC Sarmatian culture ‘growing’ out of the late Sauromatian monuments dated 4th–3rd centuries BC appeared to be rather a declarative statement without any evidence behind. Attempts to statistically analyze large sets of funeral rite signs at sites dated 6th–1st centuries BC in Asian Sarmatia did not give the expected result due to the methodological inconsistency of the study. In addition, the so-called ‘clamped dating method’ is methodologically questionable and anti-historical because the continuity of 6th–4th centuries BC culture and 2nd–1st centuries BC culture is not proven, even though the method was developed by V.M.Klepikov specifically for identifying monuments of the 3rd century BC. All the  events considered in the article led Sarmatian archeology to a crisis and to ascertaining the presence of a hiatus in chronological columns for antiquities assigned to the Scythian-Sarmatian type in the Southern Urals and the Lower Volga region.

Scythians, Sauromatians, Sarmatians, burial mountains of Asian Sarmatia, collections of archaeological sources

• Ageeva, E.I., Akishev, K.A., Kushaev, G.A., Maksimova, A.G., Senigova, T.N. 1960, Archaeological Map of Kazakhstan. Part 1. AN KazSSR, Alma-Ata. 449 p. (In Russ.)
• Glebov, V.P. 2004, “Chronology of the Early Sarmatian and Middle Sarmatian Cultures of the Lower Don Region”, Sarmatskie kultury Evrazii: Problemy regionalnoy khronologii. Doklady k 5 mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii «Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii» (“Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology. Reports to the 5^th International Conference "Problems of Sarmatian Archeology and History"). Raev and Co, Krasnodar, pp. 127–133. (In Russ.)
• Demidenko, S.V. 2007, “On one of the aspects of “the problem of the 3^rd c. B.C.” in Sarmatian archeology”, Russian archaeology, no. 2, pp. 48–54. (In Russ.)
• Zhelezchikov, B.F. 1997, “History of Archaeological Study of the Early Sarmatian Culture. Monuments of 4^th–3^d Century BC”, Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebalnykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vypusk II Rannesarmatskaya kultura (“Statistical Processing of Funerary Monuments of Asian Sarmatia. Issue II. Early Sarmatian Culture”), IA RAN, Moscow, 278 p. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 1997, On the Issue of the "Sauromatian" Culture. State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, 42 p. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 1998, Early Sarmatian Culture of 4^th–3^d Century BC. State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, 41 p. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 1999, Prokhorov Kurgans in the Southern Urals and the Problem of the Chronology of the Early Sarmatian Culture. Dissertation abstract … Candidate of Historical Sciences. State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, 24 p. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2000a, “The main problems of the chronology of the "Early Sarmatian" culture”, Rannesarmatskaya kul'tura: formirovanie, razvitie, hronologiya: Materialy IV mezhdunarodnoj konferencii «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Vyp. 1 (“Early Sarmatian culture: formation, development, chronology: Materials of the IV International conference "Problems of Sarmatian archeology and history". Iss. 1”), SNC RAN, Samara, pp. 85–104. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2000b, “On the Issue of Determining 3d Century BC Monuments in the Lower Volga Region and the Southern Urals”, Rannesarmatskaya kultura: formirovanie, razvitie, khronologiya: Materialy IV mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii «Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii». Vyp. 1 (“Early Sarmatian Culture: Formation, Development, Chronology: Materials of the 4th International Conference "Problems of Sarmatian Archeology and History". Iss. 1”), SNC RAN, Samara, pp. 75–85. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2000c, “The Barrows near the Village of Prochorovka and the Prochorov Archeological Culture in Respect to the Problem of its Chronology”, ΣΥΣΣITIA. Pamyati Yuriya Viktorovicha Andreeva (“ΣΥΣΣITIA. In memory of Yuri Viktorovich Andreev”), Aleteya, Saint Petersburg, pp. 304–330. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2003, Materials on the history of the study of Prokhorovka burial mounds in Orenburg region (following the results of the expedition of 2001), State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, 71 p. (In Russ)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2003b, “The Sarmatian Studies of M.I. Rostovtzeff and Prokhorov Kurgans”, Parfyanskij vystrel (“Parthian shot”), ROSSPEN, Moscow, pp. 580–604. (In Russ)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2004, “On Some Attempts to Update the Sarmatian Periodization”, Sarmatskie kultury Evrazii: Problemy regionalnoy khronologii. Doklady k 5 mezhunarodnoy konferentsii «Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii» (“Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology. Reports to the 5th International Conference "Problems of Sarmatian Archeology and History"), Raev and Co, Krasnodar, pp. 205–220. (In Russ.)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2013, “About the Appearance of Sarmatians in the Steppes of Eurasia According to Archaeological Data”, Bosporskiy fenomen: greki I varvary na Yevraziyskom perekrestke. materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii (“The Bosporan Phenomenon: Greeks and Barbarians at the Eurasian Crossroads: Materials of the International Scientific Conference”), Nestor-Istoriya, Saint Petersburg, pp. 512–522. (In Russ)
• Zuev, V.Yu. 2021, “On the Excavations of B.N. Grakov on the Alabaster Mountain Near the Village Nezhinsky in 1927–1928”, Arheologiya rannih kochevnikov Evrazii (“Archeology of the early nomads of Eurasia”), SGPU, Samara, pp. 14–58. (In Russ)
• Ismagilov, R.B. 1993, “Sai, Scythians and Bosporus (Research on "Classical" Scythia)”, Skify. Sarmaty. Slavyane. Rus'. Sbornik arheologicheskikh statey v chest' 56–letiya D.A. Machinskogo (“Scythians. Sarmatians. Slavs. Russia. Collection of Archaeological Articles in Honor of the 56th Anniversary of D.A. Machinsky”), Farn, Saint Petersburg, pp. 87–89. (Petersburg Archaeological Bulletin. № 6). (In Russ)
• Ismagilov, R.B. 1996, “Sarmatian window to Europe”, Aktual’nyye problemy drevney istorii i arkheologii Yuzhnogo Urala (“Actual problems of the ancient history and archaeology of the South Urals”), Vostochnyj universitet, Ufa, pp. 32–71. (In Russ.)
• Kamenetsky, I.S. 1964, “Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology in 1963”, Kratkie soobshсheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 102, p. 152. (In Russ.)
• Kamenetsky, I.S. 1966, “Work of Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology in 1964”, Kratkie soobshсheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 107, pp. 135–138. (In Russ.)
• Kamenetsky, I.S. 1967, “Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology in 1963”, Kratkie soobshсheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 112, pp. 140–142. (In Russ.)
• Klepikov, V.M. 1998, Sarmatians of the 6th–3d Century BC in the Trans-Volga and Volga-Don Interfluve. Dissertation Abstract … Candidate of Historical Sciences. Volgograd, 26 p. (In Russ.)
• Klepikov, V.M. 2002, Sarmatians of the Lower Volga region in the IV–III centuries BC. VolGU, Volgograd, 216 p. (In Russ.)
• Livshits, V.A., Zuev, V.Yu. 2004, “On dating Parthian inscriptions on goblets from barrow 1 near Prokhorovka”, Journal of Ancient History, no. 2, pp. 3–11. (In Russ.)
• Maximov, E.K. 1960, “About Chronology of Sauromatian Monuments of the Lower Volga Region”, Trudy Saratovskogo oblastnogo muzeya kraevedeniya. Vyp. III (“Proceedings of the Saratov Regional Museum of Local History. Iss. III”), SMK, Saratov, pp. 100–121. (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G. 1963a, Archaeological sites of the Prokhorovka culture. AN SSSR, Moscow, 56 p. (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G. 1963b, “Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology in 1963”, Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 94, pp. 107–110. (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G. 1974, The origins of the Early Sarmatian (Prokhorovka) culture. Nauka, Moscow, 51 p. (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G. 1989, Ways and features of development of a Savromato-Sarmatian cultural and historical community. Dissertation abstract … Candidate of Historical Sciences. Мoscow, 47 p. (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G. 2001, “On Urgent Problems of Sarmatian Archeology”, Na akad. Dmitri Sergeevich Raevski. Ἀποθέωσις (“In honorem academician Dimitri Sergeevich Raevski. Ἀποθέωσις”), New Bulgarian University, Sofia, pp. 244–249. (Mif. Iss. 7) (In Russ.)
• Moshkova, M.G., Smirnov, K.F. 1977, “Review of V.P. Shilov's Book "Essays on History of Ancient Tribes of the Lower Volga Region”, Sovetskaya arkheologiya, no. 2, pp. 265–274. (In Russ.)
• Pankov, D.I. 1911, “About Autopsy of Settlers of Burial Ground "Kos-Oba", "Caravan-Oba", the same at Site No. 90 Adamovsky of the Kustanaysky District of the Turgay Region”, Trudy OUAK (“Proceedings of the UAC”), iss. 23, pp. 129–134. (In Russ.)
• Polin, S.V. 2018, “Sarmatian Conquest of the Northern Black Sea Region (current studies)”, Drevnosti. Issledovaniya. Problemy. Sbornik statej v chest' 70-letiya N.P. Tel'nova (“Antiquities. Studies. Issues. Essays in honour of Nicolai Telnov on the occasion of his 70th birthday”), Stratum+, Kishinyov, Tiraspol', pp. 267–288. (In Russ.)
• Rostovtsev, M.I. 1918, Kurgan Finds of the Orenburg Region during Early and Late Hellenism. (With Appendices by Academician P.K. Kokovtsov and S.I. Rudenko). Ninth State Printing House of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Petrograd, 124 p. (MAR. No. 37). (In Russ.)
• Salnikov, K.V. 1940, “Sarmatian Mounds near Orsk”, Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Urala i Priuralya. T. 1: Arkheologicheskie pamyatniki Urala i Prikamya (“Materials and Research on Archeology of the Urals and the Foreurals. Vol. 1: Archaeological Sites of the Urals and the Kama Region”), AN USSR, Leningrad, pp. 128–136. (MIA. № 1). (In Russ.)
• Simonenko, A.V. 2010, Sarmatian horse riders of the Northern Black Sea region. Nestor-Istoriya, Saint Petersburg, 328 p. (In Russ.)
• Skripkin, A.S. 2017, Sarmatians. VolGU, Volgograd, 292 p. (In Russ.)
• Skripkin, A.S., Klepikov, V.M., Moshkova, M.G. 2002, “On One Attempt to Update the Sarmatian Periodization”, Russian Archaeology, no. 1, pp. 101–112. (In Russ.)
• Skrzhinskaya, M.V. 1984, “Mirrors of the Archaic Period from Olbia and Berezan”, Antichnaya kultura Severnogo Prichernomorya (“Ancient Culture of the Northern Black Sea Region”), Naukova dumka, Kyiv, pp. 105–129. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, A.P. 1961, “On Work of Sectors and Groups of the Institute of Archeology of the USSR Academy of Sciences in 1959. 1. Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology”, Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 85, pp. 130–133. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, A.P. 1962, “On Work of Sectors and Groups of the Institute of Archeology of the USSR Academy of Sciences in 1959–1960. Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology”, Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 89, pp. 118–126. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, A.P. 1963, “Sector of Scythian-Sarmatian Archeology in 1962”, Kratkie soobshheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 98, pp. 130–134. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1961, Weapons of the Sauromatians. Nauka, Moscow, 161 p. (MIA № 101) (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1962, “New Sarmatian Monuments on Buzuluk”, Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii (“Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology”), iss. 89, pp. 83–93. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1964, Sauromatians. The early history and culture of Sarmatians. Nauka, Moscow, 381 p. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1974, “Sarmatians of the Lower Volga Region and the Interfluve of the Volga and Don in the IV Century BC – II Century BC (Historical and Archaeological Essay)”, Sovetskaya arkheologiya, no. 3, pp. 33–45(In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1975, Sarmatians at the Ilek river. Nauka, Moscow, 176 pp. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F. 1977, “Sauromatians and Sarmatians”, Problemy arkheologii Evrazii i Severnoy Ameriki (“Problems of Archeology of Eurasia and North America”), Nauka, Moscow, pp. 129–139. (In Russ.)
• Smirnov, K.F., Petrenko, V.G. 1963, Savromats of the Volga Region and the Southern Urals. Nauka, Moscow, 40 p. (SAI. Iss. D1–9) (In Russ.)
• Khabdulina, M.K. 1994, Steppes of the Ishim river area in the Early Iron Age. Rakurs, Alma-Ata, 170 p. (In Russ.)
• Shilov, V.P., 1975, Essays on the History of Ancient Tribes of the Lower Volga Basin. Nauka, Leningrad, 208 p. (In Russ.)
• Shilov, V.P. 1959, “Kalinovsky Kurgan Burial Ground” Drevnosti Nizhnego Povolzhya (Itogi rabot Stalingradskoy arkheologicheskoy ekspeditsii). T. 1 (“Antiquities of the Lower Volga Region (Outcomes of the Stalingrad Archaeological Expedition). Vol. 1”), USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, pp. 323–523. (In Russ.)