Ufa Archaeological Herald

This article opens a discussion with the Volgograd archaeologist E.V.Kruglov. In his works Kruglov argues that highly decorated hand built pottery, which was discovered at Samosdelka settlement in the delta of the Volga river, belongs to the Pechenegs. Contrary to that, members of research team, who were conducting the archaeological excavations at the site, claim that it belongs to the Oğuz Turks. The idea that finds in focus are of the Oğuz origin is based on the no proven opinion of S.P.Tolstov. The scholar believes that so-called “swamp settlements” located in the lower reaches of the Syr Darya river, where similar pottery was found, refer to the Oğuz. However, data shows that the Oğuz people appear in the aforementioned region only in the middle of the 9th century AD. Thus, it is hard to link the pottery from Samosdelka with this particular ethnic group. Kazakh researchers associate this pottery with indigenous peoples of Middle and Lower Syr Darya – Kangar Pechenegs. They consider the settlement of Samosdelka as archaeological remains of Saqsin city. Abu Hamid al-Gharnati, an Arabic traveler of the 11th – 12th centuries AD, describes this city in his diaries and indicates the presence of 40 Oğuz tribes in it. This doesn’t allow us to ignore the influence of Oğuz ethnic communities in Samosdelka studies even though it is known that they were no longer masters of the steppes in the 1100s. Al-Gharnati’s books may hide the Pechenegs among the Saqsin population groups under the name of Maghrebs. In favour of this hypothesis speaks the fact that, describing the Maghrebs in Hungary and Kyiv the traveler points out that they belong to the Bjnak group (i.e. the Pechenegs). Samosdelka settlement doesn’t contain any known burials with distinct ethnic features, which makes it even more difficult to arrive to any conclusions. Numerous Muslim burials were discovered in the region and this resonates with the information about Islam spreading across Saqsin. Based on Al-Gharnati’s records and archaeological data, Saqsin was among others occupied by the Khazars (based on finds of old Turkic pottery and numerous tamghas), the Suvars (they are probable owners of so-called “general Bulgarian pottery” found in the earliest layers at Samosdelka archaeological site and having no prior ceramics tradition). Possibly, the Suvars is the other name of the Sabir peoples who came to Saqsin from the Northern Caucasus. Historical records tell us about ethnic segregation in Saqsin domain. So it seems, there was no general Saqsin community, so the Saqsins is more of a polytonym rather than an ethnonym denoting a certain nation.

город и область Саксин, Самосдельское городище, хазары, сувары, булгары, огузы, печенеги

• Vasiliev, D.V. 2004, “About the location of Saqsin city”, Problemy arheologii Nizhnego Povolzh’ya. 1 Mezhdunarodnaya Nizhnevolzhskaya arheologiches- kaya konferenciya, g. Volgograd, 1–5 noyabrya 2004 g. Tezisy dokladov (“Problems of the archeology of the Lower Volga region. 1st International Lower Volga archaeological conference, Volgograd, Novem- ber 1–5, 2004. Abstracts of reports”), VolGU, Volgograd, pp. 264–269. (In Russ.)
• Vasiliev, D.V. 2010, “Methods of processing and general characteristics of the mass materials from Samosdelka settlement”, Arheologiya Nizhnego Po- volzhya: problemy, poiski, otkrytiya. Materialy III Mezhdunarodnoj Nizhnevolzhskoj arheologicheskoj konferencii. (g. Astrahan, 18–21 oktyabrya 2010 g.)(“Archeology of the Lower Volga region: problems, searches, discoveries. Materials of 3rd International Lower Volga archaeological conference. (Astrakhan, October 18–21, 2010)”), AGU, Astrakhan, pp. 241–249. (In Russ.)
• Vasiliev, D.V. 2015, “New data on the city and the environs of Saksin”, The Volga River region archeology, no. 2(12), pp. 189–267. (In Russ.)
• Vasiliev, D.V. 2016, “Jugs”, Puteshestvie ibn Fadlana: Volzhskij put’ ot Bagdada do Bulgara: katalog vystavki (“Ibn Fadlan’s journey: the Volga river route from Baghdad to Bulghar: Exhibition Catalogue”), Mardjani Publishing House, Moscow, p. 420. (In Russ.)
• Vasiliev, D.V. 2018, “About archaeological research around the village of Samosdelka in 2018”, Perekryostki istorii. Aktual’nye problemy istoricheskoj nauki. Materialy XIV Vserossijskoj nauchnoj konferencii (g. Astrahan’, 17 maya 2018 g.) (“Crossroads of History. Current issues of historical science. Materials of 14th All-Russian scientific conference (Astrakhan, May 17, 2018)”), AGU, Astrakhan, pp. 27–29. (In Russ.)
• Vasiliev, D.V., Zilivinskaya, E.D., Grechkina, T.Y. 2003, “Samosdelka settlement – archaeological site of the Pre-Mongol period in Lower reaches of the Volga river”, Stepi Evropy v epohu srednevekovya. Tom 3. Polovecko-zolotoordynskoe vremya (“Steppes of Europe in the Middle Ages. Volume3. PolovtsianGolden Horde time”), DonNU, Donetsk, pp.83–122. (In Russ.)
• Zilivinskaya, E.D., Vasiliev, D.V., Grechkina, T.Y. 2006, “Excavations at Samosdelka settlement in Astrakhan oblast in 2000–2004”, Russian Archeology, no. 4, pp. 24–36. (In Russ.)
• Ivanov, A.A. 2000, “Early Medieval under barrow nomadic burials of the second half of the 7th – the first half of the 9th century in the Lower Don and Volga-Don interfluve region”. Dissertation ... Candidate of Historical Sciences, Volgograd, 255 p. (In Russ.)
• Klyashtorny, S.G. 2005, “Khazar Notes”, Tyurkologicheskij sbornik 2003–2004. Tyurkskie narody v drevnosti i srednevekove (“Turkology. Collection of articles 2003–2004. Turkic peoples in the Ancient times and the Middle Ages”), Oriental Literature, Moscow, pp. 95–117. (In Russ.)
• Kruglov, E.V. 2005, “To the problem of ethno cultural attribution of the peoples from the Samosdelka settlement and hand built pottery, decorated with garland-like ornaments”, Problemy doslіdzhennya pam´yatok arheologiyi Skhіdnoyi Ukrayini (“Research problems of archeological sites in Eastern Ukraine”), Shlyakh Publ., Kyiv, Lugansk, pp. 164–166. (In Russ.)
• Kruglov, E.V. 2021, “About vessels identical to the first group of hand build pottery from Samosdelka settlement”, Astrahanskie kraevedcheskie chteniya: sbornik statej (“Astrakhan regional studies readings: collection of articles”), Publisher: Roman V.Sorokin, Astrakhan, iss. 13, pp. 68–75. (In Russ.)
• Martynova, E.V. 2020, “Abandoned burials of the 11 – 13 centuries at Samosdelka settlement”, LII Uralo-Povolzhskaya arheologicheskaya konferenciya studentov i molodyh uchyonyh (UPASK, 5–9 fevralya 2020 g.): materialy Vserossijskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii studentov, aspirantov, molodyh uchenyh (“52nd Ural-Volga archaeological conference for students and young researchers (UPASK, February 5–9, 2020): Materials of All-Russian research and practical conference for students, postgraduates, young researchers”), PGNIU, Perm, pp.281–283. (In Russ.)
• Popov, P.V. 2009, “Hand built cauldrons from Samosdelka settlement and the problem of their ethnic attribution”, Stepi Evropy v epohu Srednevekov’ya. Tom 7. Hazarskoe vremya (“Steppes of Europe in the Middle Ages. Volume7. Khazar Time”), DonNU, Donetsk, pp. 153–186. (In Russ.)
• Popov, P.V. 2011, “Preliminary results of studying ceramics from Samosdelka settlement”, Samosdel’skoe gorodishche: voprosy izucheniya i interpretacii (“Samosdelka settlement: study questions and interpretations”), Astrahanskaya Cifrovaya Tipografiya, Astrakhan, pp. 60–89. (In Russ.)
• The journey of Abu Hamid al-Gharnati to Eastern and Central Europe (1131–1153). GRVL, Moscow, 1971, 136 p. (In Russ.)
• Tolstov, S.P. 1947, “Cities of Oghuz peoples (historical and ethnographic essays)”, Soviet Ethnography, no. 3, pp. 55–102. (In Russ.)
• Fedorov-Davydov, G.A. 1969, “Saqsin city and region in the 12–14 centuries”, Drevnosti Vostochnoj Evropy. Materialy i issledovaniya po arheologii (“Antiquities of Eastern Europe. Materials and research on archaeology”), no. 169, pp. 253–261. (In Russ.)
• Khlebnikova, T.A. 1984, “Ceramics from the sites of Volga Bulgaria. To the question of ethno-cultural structure of population”. Nauka, Moscow, 241 p. (In Russ.)