ISSN: 1814-1692 eISSN: 2782-2842 DOI: 10.31833/UAV
Search

Ufa Archaeological Herald

Search

Archive

Indexing
  1. Ufa Archaeological Herald
  2. →
  3. 2016
  4. →
  5. Issue 16
  6. →
  7. ARTICLES AND PUBLICATIONS
  8. →
  9. A contribution to the question of cave art dating

A contribution to the question of cave art dating

Year: 2016

Pages: 5-18

Number: 16

Type: scientific article

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31833/uav.2016.16.001

Topic: ARTICLES AND PUBLICATIONS

Authors: Serikov, Yurii B.

Download pdf

Summary:

At present time parietal art dating is provided on the basis of absolute dating the rock layer below, style correspondence with the paintings from other locations, similarity with portable art forms, graphic images on pottery and other artefacts. The article explores the unreliability of such methods and proves that only the paint analysis can help to specify the time of image creation.
  
 
 

Keywords:

parietal art, cave paintings, chronology, style, analogy, layer dating

References:

  • Bader O.N. Zhertvennoe mesto pod Pisanym kamnem na r. Vishere [Sacrificial place in Scripture the stone on the river Vishera] // SA. 1954. T. XXI.S. 241-258.
  • Bader O.N. Sledy drevnejshej peshchernoj zhivopisi na Yuzhnom Urale [Traces of the oldest cave paintings in the Southern Urals] // SA. 1961. №3. S. 319-320.
  •  
    Bader O.N. Otkrytie paleoliticheskoj peshchernoj zhivopisi na Urale [The discovery of Paleolithic cave paintings in the Urals] // Istoriko-arheologicheskij sbornik / Otv. red. D.A. Avdusin, V.L. Ianin. M.: MGU, 1962. S. 14-23.
  •  
    Bader O.N. Paleoliticheskie risunki Kapovoj peshchery (Shul'gan-Tash) na Urale [Paleolithic cave paintings Kapova (Shulgan-Tash) in the Urals] // SA. 1963. №1. S. 125-134.
  •  
    Bader O.N. Kapovaya peshchera [Kapova cave]. M.: Nauka, 1965. 49 s.
  •  
    Bibikov S.N. Neoliticheskie i ehneoliticheskie ostatki kul'tury v peshcherah Yuzhnogo Urala [Neolithic and Eneolithic cultures in the caves remains of the Southern Urals] // SA. 1950. T. XIII. S. 95-138.
  •  
    Gening V.F. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya Pisanogo kamnya na r. Vishere [Rock carvings in the stone the Written p. Vishera] // SA. 1954. T. XXI. S. 259-280.
  •  
    Guslicer B.I., Pavlov P.Yu. O pervonachal'nom zaselenii Severo-Vostoka Evropy (novye dannye) [About the original settlement of the North-East Europe (new data)]. Preprint. Syktyvkar: Komi filial AN SSSR, 1987. 24 s.
  •  
    Demeshchenko S.A. Otnositel'naya hronologiya paleoliticheskogo iskusstva malyh form i hudozhestvenno-stilisticheskie tradicii [Relative chronology of the Paleolithic art of small forms of artistic and stylistic traditions] // Mezhdunarodnaya konferenciya po pervobytnomu iskusstvu. T. I. Kemerovo: «NIKALS», 1999. S. 96-109.
  •  
    ZhilinaI.V., Petrin V.T. Original'naya industriya iz Kyshtymskogo ozyornogo kraya (k probleme poyavleniya kul'tovyh mest na Urale) [The original industry of Kyshtym Lake District (the problem of the emergence of places of worship in the Urals)] // Tekhnicheskij i social'nyj progress v ehpohu pervobytnoobshchinnogo stroya / Otv. red. V.D. Viktorova, N.G. Smirnov. Sverdlovsk: UrO AN SSSR, 1989. S. 46-53.
  • Zhitenev V.S. Kapova peshchera - mnogoslojnyj pamyatnik arheologii: predvaritel'noe soobshchenie [Kapova Cave - a multilayered monument archeology: preliminary report] // Pervobytnye drevnosti Evrazii: k 60-letiyu Alekseya Nikolaevicha Sorokina / Otv. red. S.V. Oshibkina. M.: IA RAN, 2012. S. 155-178.
  • Zhitenev V.S. Kapova peshchera v kontekste verhnego paleolita Yuzhnogo Urala [Kapova cave in the context of the Upper Palaeolithic of the Southern Urals] // Perekhodnye ehpohi v arheologii: Materialy Vseros. arheologicheskoj konf. s mezhdunar. uchastiem «XIX Ural'skoe arheologicheskoe soveshchanie». Syktyvkar: IYaLI KomiNC UrO RAN, 2013. S. 19-21.
  • Klott Zh. Poslednie dannye o peshchere Shove [Recent data on the cave of Chauvet] // Problemy pervobytnoj kul'tury / Otv. red. V.G. Kotov, V.E. Shchelinskij. Ufa: IIYaL UNC RAN, 2001. S. 18-32.
  • Kovaleva V.T., Tsapko Yu.G. Problema ehvolyutsii hudozhestvennogo stilya i kul'tury naseleniya lesnoj zony Urala v kamennom veke [The problem of the evolution of artistic style and culture of the population of the forest zone of the Urals in the Stone Age] // Voprosy arheologii Urala. Vyp. 23. Ekaterinburg: Izd-vo Ural. un-ta, 1998. S. 4-28.
  • Koksharov S.F., Shirokov V.N. Materialy po izobrazitel'noj deyatel'nosti drevnego naseleniya Urala [Materials for graphic activity of the ancient population of the Urals]. Preprint. Sverdlovsk: UrO AN SSSR, 1990. 78 s.
  • Kotov V.G. Paleolit [Paleolith] // Istoriya bashkirskogo naroda. T. I. M.: Nauka, 2009. S. 23-53.
  • Kotov V.G. Novye rezul'taty arheologicheskogo izucheniya peshchery Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoj) [New results of archaeological study of the cave Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)] // XVIII Ural'skoe arheologicheskoe soveshchanie: kul'turnye oblasti, arheologicheskie kul'tury, hronologiya. Materialy XVIII Ural'skogo arheol. soveshchaniya (11-16 oktyabrya 2010 g.). Ufa: Izd-vo BGPU, 2010. S. 74-78.
  • Kotov V.G. Issledovaniya mnogoslojnoj paleoliticheskoj stoyanki v peshchere Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoj) [Research multilayered Paleolithic cave Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)] // Problemy arheologii ehpohi kamnya: k 70-letiyu Valentiny Ivanovny Belyaevoj / Otv. red. D.G. Savinov, A.I. Murashkin. SPb.: Izd-vo S.- Peterb. gos. un-ta, 2014. S. 120-141.
  • Kotov V.G., Lyahnickij Yu.S., Piotrovskij Yu.Yu. Metodika naneseniya i sostav krasochnogo sloya risunkov peshchery Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoj) [Methods of application and composition of the paint layer of the cave drawings Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)] // UAV. Vyp. 5. 2004. S. 65-71.
  • Kuzeev R.G., Pshenichnyuk A.H. Novoe otkrytie peshchernoj zhivopisi na Yuzhnom Urale (predvaritel'nye itogi) [The new discovery of cave paintings in the Southern Urals (preliminary results)] // Issledovaniya po istoricheskoj ehtnograii Bashkirii / Otv. red. R.G. Kuzeev, L.I. Nagaeva. Ufa: BFAN SSSR, 1984. S. 144-147. Lyahnickij Yu.S. Sokrovishche paleolita [Treasure Paleolithic]. Ufa: Kitap, 2008. 188 s.
  • Lyahnickij Yu.S., Minnikov O.A., Yushko A.A. Risunki i znaki peshchery SHul'gantash (Kapovoj). Katalog izobrazhenij [Pictures and signs Shulgantash cave (Kapova). image Directory]. Ufa: Kitap, 2013. 288 s.
  • Lyahnickij Yu.S., Solodejnikov A.K. Rezul'taty issledovaniya risunkov peshchery Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoj) gruppoj VSEGEI v 2001-2004 gg. [Results of the study cave drawings Shulgan-Tash (Kapova) VSEGEI in 2001-2004.] // UAV. Vyp. 5. 2004. S. 56-64.
  • Okladnikov A.P., Petrin V.T. Novaya peshchera na Urale s paleoliticheskimi rospisyami [New Cave in the Urals with Paleolithic paintings] // Priroda. 1982. №1. S. 70-75.
  • Okladnikov A.P., Petrin V.T. Paleoliticheskie risunki Ignatievskoj peshchery na Yuzhnom Urale [Paleolithic cave paintings Ignatievskaya the Southern Urals] // Plastika i risunki drevnih kul'tur / Pervobytnoe iskusstvo / Pod red. R.S. Vasil'evskogo. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1983. S. 47-58.
  • Pavlov P.Yu. Paleoliticheskie pamyatniki Severo-Vostoka Evropejskoj chasti Rossii [Paleolithic sites of the North-East of the European part of Russia]. Syktyvkar: Komi nauchnyj centr UrO RAN, 1996. 212 s.
  • Petrin V.T. Novye dannye o pisanice s oz. Bol'shie Allaki [New data on pisanitsa a lake. Large Allakov] // SA. 1976. №1. S. 153-158.
  • Petrin V.T. K voprosu o date Araslanovskoj pisanicy na r. Ufe [To a question about the date Araslanovskoy pisanitsa on p. Ufa] // SA. 1977. №2. S. 246-249.
  • Petrin V.T. Nahodki novyh naskal'nyh izobrazhenij v Kyshtymskom ozernom krae [Found new petroglyphs in the Lake District Kyshtym] // Drevnie kul'tury Altaya i Zapadnoj Sibiri / Otv. red. V.I. Molodin. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1978. S. 66-67.
  • Petrin V.T. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya Yuzhnogo Urala [Rock Art of the Southern Urals] // Arheologiya ehpohi kamnya i metalla Sibiri / Otv. red. Yu.S. Hudyakov. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1983. S. 150-160.
  • Petrin V.T. Novye naskal'nye izobrazheniya Yuzhnogo Urala [New rock paintings of the Southern Urals] // SA. 1984. №3. S. 96-104.
  • Petrin V.T. Pisanica iz okrestnostej Sverdlovska [Pisanitsa from the vicinity of Sverdlovsk] // SA. 1985. №3. S. 119-123.
  • Petrin V.T. Novye naskal'nye izobrazheniya Urala [New rock art of the Urals] // Problemy arheologii Severnoj i Vostochnoj Azii / Otv. red. S.V. Markin. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1986. S. 99-132.
  • Petrin V.T. Paleoliticheskoe svyatilishche v Ignatievskoj peshchere na Yuzhnom Urale [Paleolithic cave Ignatievskaya sanctuary in the Southern Urals]. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1992. 207 s.
  • Petrin V.T., Shirokov V.N. Ob odnom antropomorfnom syuzhete s Shajtanskoj pisanicy [An anthropomorphic story with Shaitansky pisanitsa] // Antropomorfnye izobrazheniya / Pervobytnoe iskusstvo / Pod red. R.S. Vasil'evskogo. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1987. S. 49-57.
  • Petrin V.T., Shirokov V.N. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya yuzhnoural'skogo regiona (itogi i perspektivy issledovaniya) [Rock Art of the South Ural region (results and perspectives)] // Problemy izucheniya naskal'nyh izobrazhenij v SSSR / Otv. red. M.A. Devlet. M.: Nauka, 1990. S. 73-78.
  • Petrin V.T., Nohrina T.I., Kulik N.A., Usacheva I.V. Verhnepaleoliticheskij kompleks iz gornogo hrustalya s yugo-vostochnogo poberezh'ya ozera Bol'shie Allaki (Yuzhnyj Ural) [Upper Paleolithic complex of rock crystal from the south­east coast of the lake Big Allakov (South Urals)] // Arheologiya, ehtnograiya i antropologiya Evrazii. 2012. №4(52). S. 28-40.
  • Petrin V.T., Shirokov V.N., Chairkin S.E. Drevnee svyatilishche vo 2-oj Serpievskoj peshchere na Yuzhnom Urale [The ancient sanctuary in the 2nd Serpievskoy cave in the southern Urals] // Semantika drevnih obrazov / Pervobytnoe iskusstvo / Otv. red. R.S. Vasil'evskij. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1990. S. 7-20.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Koksharovsko-Yur'inskaya torfyanikovaya stoyanka v Srednem Zaural'e [Koksharovsko-Yurinskaya torfyanikovaya parking in the Middle Trans-Urals] // RA. 1992. №4. S. 131-147.
  • Serikov Yu.B. K voprosu o rannej date naskal'nyh izobrazhenij Urala [On the issue of the early date of the Ural rock carvings] // III Bersovskie chteniya. Materialy nauch.-prakt. konf. Ekaterinburg: Bank kul'turnoj informacii, 1999. S. 29-32.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Paleolit i mezolit Srednego Zaural'ya [Paleolithic and Mesolithic Middle Trans-Urals]. Nizhnij Tagil: NTGPI, 2000. 430 s.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Stanovlenie ritual'no-kul'tovoj praktiki u paleoliticheskogo naseleniya Urala [Formation of ritual and religious practice in the Paleolithic population of the Urals] // Mirovozzrenie naseleniya Yuzhnoj Sibiri i Central'noj Azii v istoricheskoj retrospektive. Vyp. 1 / Pod red. P.K. Dashkovskogo. Barnaul: Azbuka, 2007. S. 7-24.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Peshchernye svyatilishcha r. Chusovoj [Cave shrine p. Chusovoi]. Nizhnij Tagil: NTGSPA, 2009. 368 s.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Prirodnye ob"ekty v kul'tah i obryadah drevnego naseleniya Urala [Natural objects in the cults and rituals of the ancient population of the Urals] // Tverskoj arheologicheskij sbornik. Vyp. 9 / Materialy 13-ogo - 15-ogo zasedanij nauchno-metodicheskogo seminara «Tverskaya zemlya i sopredel'nye territorii v drevnosti». Tver': Izd-vo «Triada», 2013a. S. 31-44.
  • Serikov Yu.B. Shajtanskoe ozero -svyashchennoe ozero drevnosti [Shaitansky lake -ancient sacred lake]. Nizhnij Tagil: NTGSPA, 2013b. 408 s.
  • Solodejnikov A.K. O metodike iksacii naskal'nyh izobrazhenij v peshchere Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoj) [On the method of fixation of rock art in a cave Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)] // Kul'turnoe nasledie Yuzhnogo Urala kak innovacionnyj resurs: Materialy Vseros. nauch.-prakt. konf. «Prirodnoe i kul'turnoe nasledie Yuzhnogo Urala kak innovacionnyj resurs». Ufa: Izd-vo IIYaL UNC RAN, 2010. S. 70-84.
  • Filippov A.K. Proiskhozhdenie paleoliticheskogo iskusstva [The origin of the Palaeolithic art]. SPb.: OOO «Akadem Print», 1997. 103 s.
  • Filippov A.K. Problema ehvolyucii stilej v iskusstve paleolita [The problem of the evolution of styles in the art of the Paleolithic] // Problemy pervobytnoj kul'tury / Otv. red. V.G. Kotov, V.E. Shchelinskij. Ufa: IIYaL UNC RAN, 2001. S. 5-17.
  • Filippov A.K. Haos i garmoniya v iskusstve paleolita [Chaos and Harmony in the art of the Paleolithic]. SPb.: LOOO «Sohranenie prirody i kul'turnogo naslediya», 2004. 224 s.
  • Formozov A.A. Ocherki po pervobytnomu iskusstvu: Naskal'nye izobrazheniya i kamennye izvayaniya ehpohi kamnya i bronzy na territorii SSSR [Essays on primitive art: Rock carvings and stone sculptures of the stone and bronze in the USSR]. M.: Nauka, 1969. 256 s.
  • Formozov A.A. Pamyatniki pervobytnogo iskusstva na territorii SSSR [Monuments of primitive art in the USSR]. Izd. 2-e, dopoln. i pererab. M.: Nauka, 1980. 136 s. 
  • Formozov A.A. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya i ih izuchenie [Rock carvings and their study]. M.: Nauka, 1987. 108 s.
  • Formozov A.A. O datirovke rospisej v Ignatievskoj peshchere na Urale [On the dating of the paintings in the cave in the Urals Ignatievskaya] // RA. 2000. №1. S. 215-217.
  • Chernetsov V.N. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya Urala [Rock Art of the Urals] / SAI. Vyp. V4-12(1). Ch. 1. M.: Nauka, 1964. 51 s. 
  • Chernetsov V.N. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya Urala [Rock Art of the Urals] / SAI. Vyp. V4-12(2). Ch. 2. M.: Nauka, 1971. 118 s.
  • Shirokov V.N. Drevnejshee iskusstvo ural'skih peshcher [The Ancient Art of Ural caves]. Ekaterinburg: Sred.-Ural. kn. izd-vo, 1995. 80 s.
  • Shirokov V.N. Drevnie obrazy svyashchennyh skal [The ancient images of the sacred rock] // Kul'tovye pamyatniki gorno-lesnogo Urala. Ekaterinburg: UrO RAN, 2004. S. 63-83.
  • Shirokov V.N. Ural'skie pisanicy: Reki Rezh i Irbit [Ural pisanitsa: Rivers and Mode Irbit]. Ekaterinburg: Bank kul'turnoj informacii, 2007. 80 s.
  • Shirokov V.N. Kompozicii s risunkami ptic, kopytnyh i zmej v naskal'nyh izobrazheniyah Urala [Compositions with figures of birds, prey and snakes in the rock art of the Urals] // Ural'skij istoricheskij vestnik. 2010. №1(26). S. 92-99.
  • Shirokov V.N. Ural'skie pisanicy. Yuzhnyj Ural [Ural petroglyphs. Southern Urals]. Ekaterinburg: Izd-vo AMB, 2009. 128 s.
  • Shirokov V.N., Petrin V.T. Iskusstvo lednikovogo veka. Ignatievskaya i Serpievskaya 2 peshchery na Yuzhnom Urale [Art of Ice Ages. Ignatievskaya and Serpievskaya 2 caves in the southern Urals]. Ekaterinburg: OOO «Izdatel'skij Dom «Azhur», 2013. 190 s.
  • Shirokov V.N., Chairkin S.E. Naskal'nye izobrazheniya Severnogo i Srednego Urala [Rock Art of the Northern and Middle Ural]. Ekaterinburg: IIiA UrO RAN, 2011. 182 s.
  • Shirokov V.N., Chairkin S.E., Chemyakin Yu.P. Ural'skie pisanicy: Reka Nejva [Ural pictogram: River Neiva]. Ekaterinburg: Bank kul'turnoj informacii, 2000. 52 s.
  • Shirokov V.N., Chairkin S.E., Shirokova N.A. Ural'skie pisanicy: reka Tagil [Ural pisanitsa: river Tagil]. Ekaterinburg: Bank kul'turnoj informacii, 2005. 110 s.
  • Shirokov V.N., Rowe M.W., Steelman K.L., Southon J.R. Ignatievskaya peshchera: pervye pry-amye radiouglerodnye datirovki nastennyh risunkov [Ignatievskaya Cave: the first direct radiocarbon dat­ing of the wall paintings] // Obrazy i sakral'noe pros-transtvo drevnih ehpoh / Nauch. red. N.M. Chairki-na. Ekaterinburg: «Akva-Press», 2003. S. 67-72. 
  • Shumkin V.Ya. Monumental'noe iskusstvo Vostochnoy Laplandii kak istoricheskiy istochnik [Monumental art of Eastern Lapland as a historical source] // Slavyane i inno-ugry. Arheologiya, isto-riya i kul'tura. Doklady rossiysko-inlyandskogo simpoziuma po voprosam arheologii. SPb.: Dmitriy Bulanin, 1997. S. 32-37.
  • Shchelinskiy V.E. Issledovanie Kapovoy pesh-chery (k metodike izucheniya pervobytnyh pesh-chernyh svyatilishch) [Research Kapova cave (to the methodology of studying prehistoric cave sanctuar­ies)] // KSIA. 1990. Vyp. 202. S. 89-94.
  • Shchelinskiy V.E. Nekotorye itogi i zadachi issledovaniy peshchery Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoy) [Some results and problems of research of the cave Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)]. Ufa: IIYaL UNTS RAN, 1996. 25 s.
  • Shchelinskiy V.E. Paleogeograicheskaya sreda i arheologicheskiy kompleks verhnepaleolitichesk-ogo svyatilishcha peshchery Shul'gan-Tash (Kapo-voy) [Paleogeographic environment and the archae­ological complex of Upper Paleolithic cave shrine Shulgan-Tash (Kapova)] // Peshchernyy paleolit Urala: Materialy Mezhdunar. konf. Ufa: PRINT, 1997. S. 29-38. 
  • Shchelinskiy V.E. Nastennoe iskusstvo verh-nepaleoliticheskogo svyatilishcha v peshchere Shul'gan-Tash (Kapovoy) na Yuzhnom Urale: kom-pozitsiya «loshadi i znaki» v zale Haosa [Wall art of Upper Paleolithic cave shrine Shulgan-Tash (Kapo-va) in the Southern Urals: the song "horses and sym­bols" in the hall of Chaos] // Problemy pervobytnoy kul'tury / Otv. red. V.G. Kotov, V.E. Shchelinskiy. Ufa: IIYaL UNTs RAN, 2001. S. 33-53.
  • Yusupov R.M., Nechvaloda A.I. O nahodke chelovecheskogo cherepa v peshchere SHul'gan-Tash [On the discovery of a human skull in a cave Shulgan-Tash] // Kul'turnoe nasledie Yuzhnogo Urala kak innovatsionnyy resurs: Materialy Vseros. nauch.-prakt. konf. «Prirodnoe i kul'turnoe nasledie Yuzhnogo Urala kak innovatsionnyy resurs». Ufa: Izd-vo IIYaL UNTs RAN, 2010. S. 107-113.
  • Yakovleva L.V. Orin'yakskoe iskusstvo - formy i funktsii (Dordon' - Zhironda - Ardesh - Zhura-Suab) [Aurignacian art - form and function (Dor-dogne - Gironde - Ardeche - Jura-Suab)] // Ran-nyaya pora verhnego paleolita Evrazii: obshchee i lokal'noe. Materialy Mezhdunar. konf. k 125-leti-yu otkrytiya paleolita v Kostenkah. SPb.: Izd-vo «Nestor-Istoriya», 2006. S. 294-312.
Download pdf
up
Search
ISSN: 1814-1692 eISSN: 2782-2842 DOI: 10.31833/UAV