Ufa Archaeological Herald

The article is devoted to the study of ritual parade swords of the Scythian period. The studied topics: technology, the place of manufacturing, the relationship to the animal style decor and technological methods of manufacture, the reasons of continuity in the technique of decoration on a wide area of the Eurasian steppe. The author proceeds from the thesis that the technology of making iron weapons with gold decor is not very diverse and simple in its methods. It is based on materials of European Russia, but for comparison we used parade swords of the Asian steppe zone of the VII-III centuries BC which were manufactured by the technique of casting iron ornamented swords in eastern areas of distribution and by technology of «application» when creating plating gold decor.

Animal style of Eurasia, blacksmithing of the Scythians, decoration of the gala-ritual swords

• Kazahstana [The Issyk barrow. The Art of Kazakhstan Saks]. M.: Iskusstvo, 1978. 142 s.
• Alekseev A.Yu. Etyud ob akinakah [A study on akinaks] / V kn.: Klejn L.S. Arheologicheskaya tipologiya. L.: AN SSSR, LF TSENDISI, 1991. 442 s. S. 271-280.
• Alekseev A.Yu. Akinak ili mahajra? (Mechi iz raskopok N.I. Veselovskogo u s. Shul’govki v 1891 g.) [Akinak or mahayra? (Swords of excavations by N.I. Veselovsky by village Shulgovka in 1891)] // Drevnosti skifskoj epohi / Otv. red. L.T. Yablonskij,
  V.G. Petrenko / MIAR. T. 7. Pamyati A.I. Melyukovoj (1921-2004). M.: IA RAN, 2006. S. 43-66.
• Alekseev A.Yu. Zoloto skifskih tsarej v sobranii Ermitazha [Gold of Scythian kings in the Hermitage]. SPb.: Izd-vo Gos. Ermitazha, 2012. 272 s.
• Arheologicheskoe nasledie Volgogradskoj oblasti. K 100-letiyu Volgogradskogo arheologicheskogo muzeya [The archaeological heritage of the Volgograd region. To the 100th anniversary of the Archaeological Museum of Volgograd] / Gl. red. A.S. Skripkin. Volgograd: Izdatel’, 2013. 288 s.
• Arzhan II. Katalog vystavki [Arzhan II. The exhibition catalog]. SPb.: Gos. Ermitazh, Slaviya, 2004. 67 s.
• Bessonova S.S. O kul’te oruzhiya u skifov [About the cult of weapons of the Scythians] // Vooruzhenie skifov i sarmatov / Pod red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1984. S. 3-22.
• Berezutskij V.D., Zolotarev P.M. Kinzhal skifskogo vremeni iz s. Shubnoe Ostrogozhskogo rajona [Dagger of the Scythian time from village Shubnoe of Ostrogozhsk district] // Vostochnoevropejskie drevnosti. Voronezh: Izdat.-poligraf. tsentr «Nauchnaya kniga», 2012. S. 185-189.
• Voroshilov A.N. Vooruzhenie naseleniya lesostepnogo Podon’ya v skifskoe vremya: akinaki, kop’ya, drotiki: Diss. ... kand. istorich. nauk [The armament of the population in the forest-steppe Don region in Scythian time: akinaks, spears, darts: Diss. ...
  cand. historical. sciences]. 07.00.06. Voronezh, 2007.222 s.
• Voroshilov A.N. Vooruzheniya rannih kochevnikov v verhov’yah Tsny (regional’nye osobennosti) [Weapons of early nomads in the upper flow of Tsna (regional peculiarities)] // Tambovskie drevnosti. Arheologiya Oksko-Donskoj ravniny. Vyp. 3 / Otv. red. S.I. Andreev. Tambov: Izdat. dom TGU im. G.R. Derzhavina, 2010. S. 102-105.
• Voroshilov A.N. Akinaki kelermesskogo tipa v donskoj lesostepi [Akinaks of Kelermes type in the Don forest-steppe] // Vostochnoevropejskie drevnosti skifskoj epohi (Vestnik Ostrozhskogo istorikohudozhestvennogo muzeya im. I.N. Kramskogo) / Otv. red. A.N. Voroshilov. Voronezh: Nauchnaya kniga, 2011. S. 156-168.
• Voroshilov A.N., Medvedev A.P. Vooruzhenie naseleniya lesostepnogo Podon’ya v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya [The armament of the population of foreststeppe Don region in the Scythian-Sarmatian time] // Vooruzhenie sarmatov: regional’naya tipologiya i hronologiya. Doklady k VI mezhdunar. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Chelyabinsk: Izd-vo YuUrGU, 2007. S. 76-98.
• Gabuev T.A. Alanskij vsadnik. Sokrovishcha knyazej I-XII vv. n.e.: Katalog vystavki [The Alanian rider. Treasures of the IX-XII centuries BC princes: Exhibition catalog]. M.: GMINV, 2005. 74 s.
• Galanina L.K. Kelermesskie kurgany. «Tsarskie» pogrebeniya ranneskifskoj epohi [Kelermes mounds. “Royal” burials of Early Scythian era] / Stepnye narody Evrazii. T. 1. M.: Paleograf, 1997. 316 s.
• Gerodot. Istoriya [History]. V 9-ti kn. / Per. G.A. Stratanovskogo. M.: Izd-vo AST, Ladomir, 2001. 752 s.
• Grakov B.N. Starejshie nahodki zheleznyh veshchej v evropejskoj chasti territorii SSSR [The oldest finds of iron artifacts in the European part of the USSR] // SA. №4. 1958. S. 3-9.
• Grebennikov Yu.S., Nedopako D.P. Skifskij mech s Nizhnego Pobuzh’ya [A Scythian sword from the Lower Bug] // Vooruzhenie skifov i sarmatov / Pod red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1984. S. 126-128.
• Grebennikov Yu.S. Kimmerijtsy i skify Stepnogo Pobuzh’ya (IX-III vv. do n.e.) [Cimmerians and Scythians of the Steppe Bug area (XI-III centuries BC)]. Nikolaev: Ilion, 2008. 192 s.
• Gulyaev V.I., Savchenko E.I. Novoe pogrebenie znatnogo voina skifskoj epohi na srednem Donu [New burial of a noble warrior of Scythian epoch on the middle Don] // Arheologiya, etnografiya i antropologiya Evrazii. № 1. 2000. S. 88-94.
• Gulyaev V.I. Obshchie problemy arheologii Srednego Dona skifskogo vremeni [Common problems of archeology of the Middle Don Scythian time] // Arheologiya Srednego Dona v skifskuyu epohu. Trudy Potudanskoj arheologicheskoj ekspeditsii IA RAN
  1993-2000 gg. / Otv. red. V.I. Gulyaev. M.: IA RAN, 2001. S. 18-52.
• Gulyaev V.I. Eshche raz k voprosu ob etnokul’turnoj situatsii v Srednem Podon’e v skifskoe vremya (V-IV vv. do n.e.) [Once again on the question of ethno-cultural situation in the Middle Don region in the Scythian time (V-IV century BC)] // Arheologiya
  Srednego Dona v skifskuyu epohu. Trudy Donskoj (Potudanskoj) arheologicheskoj ekspeditsii IA RAN 2001-2003 gg. / Otv. red. V.I. Gulyaev. M.: IA RAN, 2004. S. 7-25.
• Gulyaev V.I. O nekotoryh motivah zverinogo stilya v iskusstve naseleniya Srednego Dona skifskoj epohi [On some motifs of the animal style in the art of the population of the Middle Don in Scythian epoch] // Vostochnoevropejskie drevnosti (Vestnik Ostrogozhskogo istoriko-hudozhestvennogo muzeya im. I.N. Kramskogo. Vyp. 2) / Otv. red. Yu.D. Razuvaev. Voronezh: Nauchnaya kniga, 2012. S. 125-154.
• Gulyaev V.I., Savchenko E.I. Novye nahodki predmetov skifskogo «zverinogo stilya» v kurganah Srednego Dona [New finds of objects of the Scythian «animal style» in the Middle Don mounds] // Problemy arheologii bassejna Dona / Otv. red. A.D. Pryahin. Voronezh: Voronezhskij gos. ped. un-t, 1999. S. 199-207.
• Zolotye oleni Evrazii: Katalog vystavki v Gos. Ermitazhe [Golden Deers of Eurasia: Catalog of the exhibition in the State Hermitage]. SPb., 18.X.2001 g. – 20.I.2002 g. SPb.: Slaviya, 2001. 248 s.
• Itina M.A., Yablonskij L.T. Saki Nizhnej Syrdar’i (po materialam mogil’nika Yuzhnyj Tagisken) [The Saks of the Lower Syr-Darya (based on the South Tagisken burial)]. M.: Rossijskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), 1997. 187 s.
• Kantorovich A.R. Klassifikatsiya i tipologiya elementov zoomorfnyh prevrashchenij v zverinom stile Stepnoj Skifii [Classification and typology of the elements of zoomorphic transformations in animal style of the Steppe Scythia] // Strukturnosemioticheskie
  issledovaniya v arheologii. T. 1 / Otv. red. A.V. Evglevskij. Donetsk: IA NANU, Donets.
  nats. un-t, 2002. S. 77-130.
• Kantorovich A.R. Istoki i variatsii obrazov grifona i grifonopodobnyh sushchestv v ranneskifskom zverinom stile VII-VI vv. do n.e. [The origins and variations of images and the griffin and griffin like creatures in the early Scythian animal style VII-VI centuries BC] // Izobrazitel’noe iskusstvo v arheologicheskom nasledii (Arheologicheskij al’manah. №21) / Gl. red. A.V. Kolesnik. Donetsk: Lebed’, 2010. S. 189-225.
• Kantorovich A.R. Vostochnoevropejskij stil’ i predmety skifskogo vooruzheniya [Eastern European style and items of the Scythian weaponry] // Vojna i voennoe delo v skifo-sarmatskom mire: Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf., posvyashch. pamyati
  A.I. Melyukovoj / Otv. red. S.I. Luk’yashko. Rostov n/D: Izd-vo YuNTs RAN, 2014. S. 130-141.
• Korol’kova E.F. Zverinyj stil’ Evrazii. Iskusstvo plemyon Nizhnego Povolzh’ya i Yuzhnogo Priural’ya v skifskuyu epohu (VII-IV vv. do n.e.). Problemy stilya i etnokul’turnoj prinadlezhnosti [The Animal style of Eurasia. The Art of tribes of the Lower Volga and Southern Urals in the Scythian epoch (VII-IV centuries BC). Style problems and ethnic and cultural affiliation]. SPb.: Peterburgskoe Vostokovedenie, 2006. 272 s.
• Kotov V.G., Ismagil R. Semantika dekorirovannogo oruzhiya rannih kochevnikov Evrazii [The semantics of the decorated weapons of early nomads of Eurasia] // UAV. 2013. Vyp. 13. S. 68-90.
• Kravtsova M.E. Iskusstvo [The art] // Duhovnaya kul’tura Kitaya. Entsiklopediya v 5 t. T. 6 (dopolnitel’nyj) / Gl. red. M.L. Titarenko. M.: Vostochnaya literatura, 2010. S. 306-311.
• Medvedev A.P. Rannij zheleznyj vek lesostepnogo Podon’ya. Arheologiya i etnokul’turnaya istoriya I tys. do n.e [The Early Iron Age forest-steppe Don region. Archaeology and ethno-cultural history of Ist millennium BC]. M.: Nauka, 1999. 160 s.
• Melyukova A.I. Vooruzhenie skifov [Armament of Scythians] / SAI. Vyp. D1-4. M.: Nauka, 1964. 113 s.
• Melyukova A.I. Skifiya i frakijskij mir [Scythia and the Thracian world]. M.: Nauka, 1979. 256 s.
• Minasyan R.S. Sibirskie kinzhaly skifskogo vremeni [Sibirian daggers of Scythian time] // SGE. Vyp. LXII. SPb., 2004. S. 68-72.
• Minasyan R.S. Metalloobrabotka v drevnosti i srednevekov’e [Metalworking in antiquity and the Middle Ages]. SPb.: Izd-vo GE, 2014a. 472 s.
• Minasyan R.S. Zolotoj dekor na zheleznyh mechah iz Filippovskih kurganov [Golden decoration on the iron swords of the Filippovka mounds] // Sarmaty i vneshnij mir. Materialy VIII Vseros. (s mezhdunar. uchastiem) nauch. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii», Ufa, IIYaL UNTs RAN, 12-15 maya 2014 g. / Otv. red. L.T. Yablonskij, N.S. Savelev. (UAV. Vyp. 14). Ufa: IIYaL UNTs RAN, Tsentr «Nasledie», 2014b. S. 141-146.
• Ol’hovskij V.S., Evdokimov G.L. Skifskie izvayaniya VII-III vv. do n.e. [Scythian sculptures of VII-III centuries BC]. M.: MTO Meteo, 1994. 188 s.Otroshchenko V.V. Paradnyj mech iz kurgana u s. Velikaya Belozerka [Ceremonial sword from a barrow in Great Belozerka] // Vooruzhenie skifov i sarmatov / Pod red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1984. S. 121-126.
• Perevodchikova E.V. Yazyk zverinyh obrazov. Ocherki iskusstva evrazijskih stepej skifskoj epohi [Language of animal images. Sketches of Eurasian steppe art of Scythian epoch]. M.: Vostochnaya literatura, 1994. 206 s.
• Perevodchikova E.V. Filippovka i Altaj (po materialam zolotyh predmetov iz 1 Filippovskogo kurgana) [Filippovka and Altai (based on gold objects from 1st Filippovsky mound)] // Kamennaya skul’ptura i melkaya plastika drevnih i srednevekovyh narodov Evrazii (Tr. SAIPI. Vyp. 3) / Otv. red. A.A. Tishkin. Barnaul: Azbuka, 2007. S. 60-62. 
• Perevodchikova E.V. Eshche raz o yugovostochnyh svyazyah Filippovskih kurganov [Once again on the south-eastern links of the Filippovka mounds] // Arheologiya i paleoantropologiya Evrazijskih stepej i sopredel’nyh territorij (MIAR. №13) / Otv. red. M.M. Gerasimova, V.Yu. Malashev, M.G. Moshkova. M.: Taus, 2010. S. 295-298.
• Pogrebova M.N., Raevskij D.S. Rannie skify i drevnij Vostok. K istorii stanovleniya skifskoj kul’tury [Early Scythians and the ancient East. On the history of the formation of the Scythian culture]. M.: Nauka, 1992. 260 s.
• Polidovich Yu.B. Izobrazheniya na klinkah kinzhalov i mechej skifo-sakskogo vremeni [Images on the blades of daggers and swords of the Scythian-Saka time] // Voskhozhdenie k vershinam arheologii: sbornik materialov mezhdunar. nauch. konf. «Drevnie i srednevekovye gosudarstva na territorii Kazahstana», posvyashch. 90-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya K.A. Akisheva / Otv. red. K.M. Bajpakov. Almaty,2014. S. 257-272.
• Puzikova A.I. Akinak iz s. Klyuch Kurskoj oblasti [Akinak from the Klyuch village, Kursk region] // Drevnosti Evrazii v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya / Pod red. A.I. Milyukovoj, M.G. Moshkovoj, V.G. Petrenko. M.: Nauka, 1984. S. 210-213.
• Puzikova A.I. Kurgannye mogil’niki skifskogo vremeni Srednego Podon’ya (Publikatsii kompleksov) [Burial mounds of the Scythian period of the Middle Don region (publication of archaeological complexes)]. M.: Indrik, 2001. 271 s.
• Raevskij D.S. Model’ mira skifskoj kul’tury [Model of the World of Scythian culture]. M.: Yazyki slavyanskih kul’tur, 2006. 600 s.
• Rukavishnikova I.V. Vozmozhnosti izucheniya kompozitsij zverinogo stilya rannego zheleznogo veka kak arheologicheskogo istochnika na primere zverinogo stilya Sayano-Altaya [The possibilities of studying compositions of the animal style of the early Iron Age as an archaeological source on the example of the animal style of the Sayano-Altai] // Izobrazitel’noe iskusstvo v arheologicheskom nasledii (Arheologicheskij al’manah. №21) / Gl. red. A.V. Kolesnik. Donetsk: Lebed’, 2010. S. 287-319.
• Rukavishnikova I.V. Dekor mecha iz mogil’nika Filippovka I [The decor of the sword from the burial ground Filippovka I] // Drevnost’: istoricheskoe znanie i spetsifika istochnika. Materialy mezhdunar. nauch. konf., posvyashch. pamyati E.A. Grantovskogo i D.S. Raevskogo. Vyp. V / Otv. red. A.S. Balahvantsev, G.Yu. Kolganova. M.: In-t vostokovedeniya RAN, 2011. S. 176-182. 
• Ryazanov S.V. Kuznechnaya tekhnika savromatosarmatskogo klinkovogo oruzhiya iz Bashkortostana [Forging techniques of Sauromate-Sarmatian bladed weapons from Bashkortostan] // Yuzhnyj Ural i sopredel’nye territorii v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya:
  Sb. statej k 70-letiyu A.H. Pshenichnyuka / Otv. red. G.T. Obydennova, N.S. Savelev. Ufa: Gilem, 2006. S. 137-140.
• Savchenko E.I. Vooruzhenie i predmety snaryazheniya naseleniya skifskogo vremeni na Srednem Donu [Weapons and equipment items of the population of the Scythian period in the Middle Don] // Arheologiya Srednego Dona v skifskuyu epohu. Trudy Donskoj (Potudanskoj) arheologicheskoj ekspeditsii IA RAN, 2001-2003 gg. / Otv. red. V.I. Gulyaev. M.: IA RAN, 2004. S. 151-277.
• Sarapulkina T.V. Mech skifskogo tipa s territorii Belgorodskoj oblasti [Scythian type sword from the territory of the Belgorod region] // Vostochnoevropejskie drevnosti (Vestnik Ostrogozhskogo istorikohudozhestvennogo muzeya im. I.N. Kramskogo. Vyp. 2) / Otv. red. Yu.D. Razuvaev. Voronezh: Nauchnaya kniga, 2012. S. 182-184.Skoryj S.A. Skify v Dneprovskoj Pravoberezhnoj Lesostepi (problema vydeleniya iranskogo etnokul’turnogo elementa) [The Scythians in the Dniper Right Bank Forest-Steppe (the problem of determining the Iranian ethnic and cultural elements)]. Kiev: IA NANU, 2003. 197 s.
• Skripkin A.S. Klinkovoe oruzhie rannih kochevnikov Nizhnego Povolzh’ya VII-IV vv. do n.e. [Bladed weapons of early nomads of the Lower Volga Region, VII-IV centuries BC] // Vooruzhenie sarmatov: regional’naya tipologiya i hronologiya. Doklady k VI mezhdunar. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Chelyabinsk: Izd-vo YuUrGU, 2007. S. 38-51.
• Smirnov K.F. Savromaty. Rannyaya istoriya i kul’tura sarmatov [The Sauromates. Early History and Culture of Sarmatians]. M.: Nauka, 1964. 381 s.
• Sulajmanov E. Traditsii obrabotki metallov u kirgizov [Traditions of metalworking of Kirghizes]. Frunze: Ilim, 1982. 102 s.
• Tairov A.D. Kochevniki Uralo-Kazahstanskih stepej v VII-VI vv. do n.e. [Nomads of Ural-Kazakhstan steppes in the VII-VI centuries BC]. Chelyabinsk: Izdvo YuUrGU, 2007. 277 s.
• Tairov A.D. Nekotorye obraztsy klinkovogo oruzhiya rannego zheleznogo veka iz Yuzhnogo Zaural’ya [Some samples of bladed weapons of the early Iron Age of Southern Trans-Urals] // Vooruzhenie sarmatov: regional’naya tipologiya i hronologiya. Doklady k VI mezhdunar. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Chelyabinsk: Izd-vo YuUrGU, 2007. S. 24-29.
• Tatarinov S.I. Zhelezodelatel’nyj gorn bondarihinskoj kul’tury [Ironworks forge of the Bondarihinsk culture] // SA. №3. 1980. S. 280-283.
• Terenozhkin A.I. Kimmerijtsy [The Cimmerians]. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1976. 223 s.
• Terekhova N.N., Erlih V.R. Drevnejshie stal’nye izdeliya na Severo-Zapadnom Kavkaze (k probleme kul’turnyh kontaktov v predskifskoe vremya) [The oldest steel products in the North-West Caucasus (to the problem of cultural contacts in the Scythian time)] // Kimmerowie, Scytowie, Sarmaci. Księga poświęcona pamięci Profesora Tadeusza Sulimirskiego. Kraków, 2004. Р. 431-445.
• Topal D.A. Akinaki klassicheskoj Skifii: tip Soloha [Akinaks of classical Scythia: the Solokha type] // Vojna i voennoe delo v skifo-sarmatskom mire: Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf., posvyashch. pamyati A.I. Melyukovoj / Otv. red. S.I. Luk’yashko. Rostov n/D: Izd-vo YuNTs RAN, 2014a. S. 380-407.
• Topal D.A. Final’naya liniya razvitiya mechej klassicheskoj Skifii. Sootnoshenie tipov Chertomlyk i Shul’govka [The final line of development of the classic swords Scythia. Value types and Chertomlyk Shulgovka] // Stratum plus. № 3. 2014b. S. 129-156.
• Tsybul’skaya O.N., Buravlev I.Yu., Yudakov A.A., Nikitin Yu.G. Sohranenie arheologicheskogo metalla: ucheb. Posobie [Preservation of archaeological metal: a manual]. Vladivostok: Dal’nauka, 2012. 89 s.
• Chernenko E.V. O serijnom proizvodstve paradnogo oruzhiya skifskogo vremeni v antichnyh tsentrah Severnogo Prichernomor’ya [About the serial production of ceremonial weapons of the Scythian period in the ancient center of the northern Black Sea region] // Tez. dokl. Vsesoyuznoj nauch. konf. «Problemy antichnoj istorii i klassicheskoj filologii». Har’kov, 1980a. S. 67-69.
• Chernenko E.V. Drevnejshie skifskie paradnye mechi (Mel’gunov i Kelermess) [The ancient Scythian ceremonial swords (Mel’gunov and Kelermes)] // Skifiya i Kavkaz / Otv. red. A.I. Terenozhkin. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1980b. S. 7-13.
• Chernikov S.S. Zagadka Zolotogo kurgana [Riddle of the Golden mound]. M.: Nauka, 1965. 189 s.
• Chotbaev A. Vooruzhenie drevnih kochevnikov kazahskih stepej [The armament of the ancient nomads of the Kazakh steppes]. Astana: Filial In-ta arheologii im. A.H. Margulana, 2013. 200 s.
• Chugunov K.V. Kinzhal-akinak iz kurgana Arzhan 2 [Dagger akinak from Arzhan 2 mound] // SGE. LXII. SPb., 2004. S. 72-74.
• Chugunov K.V. Nekotorye osobennosti iskusstva kurgana Arzhan-2 [Some features of art from Arzhan-2 barrow] // Trudy II (XVIII) Vseros. arheol. s”ezda v Suzdale. T. II. M.: IA RAN, 2008. S. 98-101.
• Shramko B.A. Iz istorii skifskogo vooruzheniya [From the history of the Scythian weapons] // Vooruzhenie skifov i sarmatov / Pod red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1984. S. 22-39.
• Hazanov A.M., Shkurko A.I. Sotsial’nye i religioznye osnovy skifskogo iskusstva [Social and religious foundations of Scythian art] // Skifo-sibirskij zverinyj stil’ v iskusstve narodov Evrazii / Pod red. A.I. Melyukovoj, M.G. Moshkovoj. M.: Nauka, 1976. S. 40-51.
• Yablonskij L.T., Rukavishnikova I.V. Vooruzhenie rannesarmatskogo voina (po materialam Filippovskogo mogil’nika) [Armament of the early Sarmatian warrior (based on Filippovka burial ground)] // Vooruzhenie sarmatov: regional’naya tipologiya i hronologiya. Doklady k VI mezhdunar. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Chelyabinsk: Izd-vo YuUrGU, 2007. S. 16-24.
• Yablonskij L.T. Oruzhie rannih sakov [Weapons of early Saka] // Vooruzhenie sarmatov: regional’naya tipologiya i hronologiya. Doklady k VI mezhdunar. konf. «Problemy sarmatskoj arheologii i istorii». Chelyabinsk: Izd-vo YuUrGU, 2007. S. 134-142.
• Yablonskij L.T., Rukavishnikova I.V., Shemahanskaya M.S. «Zolotoj» mech iz tsarskogo kurgana № 4 mogil’nika Filippovka 1 [«Gold» sword from the king’s burial mound number 4 of Filippovka 1 burial] // VDI. 2011. № 4. C. 219-243.
• Soo, J.F., Bunker, E. Traders and Raiders on China’s Northern Frontier. Seattle: Arthur M. Sackler Gallery in association with University of Washington Press, 1995. 203 p.
• Bunker, E.C. Artifacts: regional styles and methods of production / Nomadic Art of the Eastern Eurasian Steppes. The Metropoliten museum of art. New York, 2002. P. 15-37.
• Cugunov, K., Parzinger, H., Nagler, A. Der skythenzeitliche Furstenkurgan Arzan 2 in Tuva. Mainz: Verlag Philipp von Zabern. Archaologie in Eurasien. Band 26. 2010. 330 S.
• Rawson, J. Chinese Bronzes, Art and Ritual. London: Published for the Trustees of the British Museum in association with the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts, University of East Anglia, 1987.
• Rawson, J. Mysteries of Ancient China. New Discoveries from the early Dynasties. British Museum Press // Arts Asiatiques. 1996. Tome 52. P. 158-160.
• Янь ся ду (Нижняя столица Янь) / Хэбэй шэн вэньу яньцзюсо (НИИ культурного наследия провинции Хэбэй). Т. 1-2. Пекин: Вэньу чубаньшэ. 1996. Т. 1: 39, 947 с.; Т. 2: 56, 192 с.